Who is Muhammad?
Muhammad, the founder of Islam, was a native of Arabia and
a Semite by race. He was born on April 20th, 571 AD, in
the city of Mecca (historical accounts differ on the exact
date). The year 571 is called the Year of the Elephant,
later linked to a Surah (chapter) in the Quran, designating
the Christian Ethiopian general Abraha’s unsuccessful
attempt to capture Mecca with war elephants upon learning
of the desecration of Christian sites. Muslims believe that
the defeat of Abraha in the same year of Muhammad’s
birth is a prophetic sign from Allah to Muhammad as the
future conqueror of non-Muslim religions. Muhammad belonged
to the Hashimite clan of the tribe of Quraysh, who controlled
the Kaaba shrines that contained a number of polytheistic
and pagan religions.
His father’s name was Abed Allah, indicating that
the term Allah was used in pre-Islamic paganism. Some argue
that the term Allah is purely Arabic and has nothing to
do with the biblical name Elohim. In any case, Muhammad
was orphaned at an early age and was raised by his grandfather
Abed Almutalib. At the death of Abed Almutalib, Muhammad
came under the guardianship of uncle Abu Talib, the head
of the Hashimite clan. He was breast-fed by a bedouin woman
named Halima. In the Arabic culture boys, being more favored
than girls, usually are suckled longer. Nevertheless, it
was here among the bedouins where Muhammad learned the classical
Arabic language, which proved to be an important factor
in his later religious life. Muslims claim that Muhammad
was illiterate and unable to compose an excellent Arabic
book like the Quran; therefore the Quran must be an authentic
revelation from Allah. A number of scholars such as Tisdall,
Saal and Pfander efficiently dispute such a claim.
Muhammad was familiar to a large degree with other religious
practices, including Christianity and Judaism. According
to the Muslim historian, Hassan Ibrahim, he was exposed
first hand to Christian teaching from a Syrian Nestorian
monk during his many commercial travels to Syria. Moreover,
according to Harpers Dictionary of Religion, in his quest
for religious answers, Muhammad looked first to the religious
traditions around him for the answers. Muhammad was not
alone in his search for religious truth. Muslim tradition
tells of at least three men who broke with polytheism and
adopted some form of monotheism just before or during Muhammad’s
time. They are called Hanifs (true seekers of worshiping
God, analogous to Bible’s designation of ‘God’s
feared’) they were: 1. Waraka ibn Nawfal, Khadija’s
cousin, who converted to Christianity; 2. Ubaydallah ibn
Jahsh, who converted to Islam after Muhammad’s mission,
but later became a Christian; 3. Uthman ibn al-Huwayrith,
who went to the Byzantine court, became a Christian and
received high office.
Muhammad’s material success in this part of his life
is attributed to his commercial association with the rich
widow, Khadija, and his later marriage to her. It is not
clear whether she or any in her family provided Muhammad
with any religious instruction, but she was related to the
Christian scholar, Waragah ibn Nawfal, who memorized large
portions of the Bible. She did give Muhammad social standing
and considerable personal support during his early religious
experiences. She was the mother of all of Muhammad’s
children except Ibrahim. His three sons by her, died in
infancy, as did Ibrahim. Muhammad’s new social status
enabled him to assume a central role in the rebuilding of
the Kaaba, although later narrators have embellished the
particulars of the story.
Muhammad exercised an annual ascetic withdrawal in cave
Hira around Mecca. Not much is known exactly about his routine
but it lasted for approximately a month each year. Muhammad
claimed that he received the first revelation by angel Gabriel
on Mt. Hira, a mountain near Mecca. Frightened by this encounter,
Muhammad doubted this revelation, believing it was from
Satan, and contemplated killing himself to avoid being thought
insane (which his critics called him anyway). When he encountered
visions of revelations, he experienced bodily changes evident
to those around him. He was accused of seizures or epilepsy,
and some went so far to suggest it was satanic. However,
Muhammad came back to his wife Khadija and her Christian
cousin Waraka ibn Nawfal, who encouraged him and persuaded
him that it was a valid revelation from Allah, similar to
that of Old and New Testament revelations.
He persuaded few to accept his new religion including his
wife Khadija. However, his initial success was faced with
opposition from the Meccan tribes who refrained from harming
him for fear of embarking on a civil war, particularly Muhammad's
Hashimite clan, who supported him more out of tribal loyalty
than from conviction in his religious mission. After failing
to recruit the Meccans to his religion, Muhammad moved to
Medina and succeeded in uniting its various factions agains
the Meccans, and established the first Muslim Community
(umma) and ruled it strictly under the injunction of the
Quran. In 630 AD Muhammad succeeded in conquering Mecca
making it the center of his religion. Between 630 and 632
AD, he subjugated Arabia, thus turning it from a pre-Islamic
multi-ethnic and culturally diverse society to an exclusive
Muhammad became ill and died in June of 632 and buried
at Medina where his tomb becomes a major attraction for
Muslims. Muhammad died without providing a successor. Later
a series of successors called caliphs, carried on the task
of ruling and expanding the Ummah, which was established
by Muhammad in Medina. Today the term Ummah refers to Islam
What does the term ‘Islam’ means?
The word “Islam” has at least three shades of
meaning. First, the term is derived from the Arabic verb
“aslama.” When a combatant surrenders his weapon
in defeat, we use the term “aslama” indicating
“he submits.” Second, the general usage of the
term refers the religion founded by Muhammad signifies the
religion of submission or resignation-presumably to the
will of Allah. Third, the noun form “Islam”
refers to the total belief system introduced by Muhammad
including the practices of the religion. The followers are
known as ‘Muslims’ sometimes spelled ‘Moslems.’
It is interesting that an increasing number of Muslims-particularly
in the west, allege that the term ‘Islam’ is
also derived from the root word for peace (salam). This
is incorrect. Though similar in inflection, it does not
agree with the etymological derivation as examined by the
authoritative Arabic Al-Munjid dictionary’s definition.
The Arabic term “salema” means to be delivered
or safeguarded (i.e. peace). However, the term “aslama”
as mentioned above, is a military and combative designation
meaning to embrace Islam by surrendering to the religion,
as well to Allah’s will. Thus, the root for the word
peace “salam” is not found here.
What do Muslims believe?
Muslims “Iman” (belief) is normally divided
into five categories:
Third, Quran and previous revelations.
Fifth, the Day of Judgment.
Let us look at each briefly:
Firstly, the belief in Allah as a supreme deity. There
is a definite emphasis on the “Tawheed” (Oneness)
of Allah, who has no partners. This reactionary emphasis
germinated in the mind of Muhammad largely because of misconceptions
about the pristine Christian teaching on the Trinity, as
we mentioned earlier.
Secondly, the belief in Angels. Muslims believe that angels
are created from light by Allah, and they are part of his
invisible macrocosm to serve his purposes. There are other
kinds of invisible creatures made of fire, called ‘jinn’
(Eng. Genie). They possess exceptional power. Some are good,
others evil, and can influence human affairs.
The biblical teaching about Angels goes further. The central
role of angels in the New Testament is to advance the work
of redemption of the Lord Jesus Christ. They participated
in the three great salvation events: the incarnation (Matthew
1:20; Luke, 1:26); the death and resurrection (Matthew 28:2,
Luke 24:4) ; and the culmination of the work of redemption
Thirdly, the belief in the Quran and previous revelations.
These are divided into four categories: 1- The books of
Moses (Tawrat); 2- The ‘Zabur’ (book of Psalms);
3- The ‘Injil’ (Gospel); 4- the Quran, which
Muslims claim to be the final and actual revelation from
Allah. Muslims have charged both Christians and Jews with
falsifying their scriptures and believe that the Quran has
abrogated the previous revelations and replaced it.
There are several reasons for Muslims claim about the alleged
falsification of the Bible:
First, there is vexation among Muslims about the Jewish
and Christians rejection of their prophet, since the Old
and New testaments do not predict the coming of Muhammad.
Muslim scholars reacted to such affirmation by attempting
to find illusions or references to Muhammad in the Bible
(more on that later).
Second, there are intellectual objections to the biblical
affirmations. It goes something like this: we Muslims do
not understand nor accept the Christian teaching on the
Trinity or Jesus as the son of God; nor do we accept that
God would allow Jesus to die such an appalling death on
Third, Muslims deduce that the usage of several versions
of the Bible by the Christians today is a proof of its inaccuracy.
It suffices to say that not being able to understand the
mysteries of God spoken of in the Bible is not grounds for
rejecting it. It is like saying, I do not accept the Bible
because I don’t understand it and I don’t like
what I read. Our likes or dislikes are irrelevant. Because
the Bible does not predict Muhammad and has some difficult
teaching, we cannot say it must be corrupted and there must
be a need for another book like the Quran to replace it.
This logic is self-defeating.
Sad to say, because of such allegations and misconceptions,
ingrained in the minds of Muslims throughout their history,
many of them have dismissed or at least doubted the Gospel
message. However, here are seven questions Muslims must
address before they challenge the authenticity of the Bible:
1. How can it be that both Jews and Christians conspire
to alter their sacred books with no one knowing about it?
2. Did they amass all the written Scriptures from all geographical
locations in order to perpetrate such a forgery with no
one single charge against them by any one except Muslims
who came to the scene six hundred years later?
3. Can any Muslims produce one shred of evidence to show
that the Bible has been altered?
4. Can any Muslims tell us when it was altered?
5. Can Muslim scholars tell us why both Christian and Jews
determined to alter their most sacred Scriptures. What would
they gain from such conduct by defying its command that
prohibits them to do so? It is important in this connection
to look at some of the biblical teaching on its authority
and inerrancy of its content; and how it warns any one who
attempts to alter it:
- “And the words of the LORD are flawless, like silver
refined in a furnace of clay,” (Psalms 12:6);
- “Sanctify them by Your truth; Your word is truth.”
(John 17:17); “All Scripture is God breathed and is
useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in
righteousness,” (2 Timothy 3:16);
- “For prophecy never had its origin in the will of
man, but men spoke from God as they were carried along by
the Holy Spirit.” (2 Peter 1:21);
- "You shall not add to the word which I command you,
nor take from it, that you may keep the commandments of
the LORD your God which I command you.” (Deuteronomy
- "Do not add to what I command you and do not subtract
from it, but keep the commands of the LORD your God that
I give you.";
- “Your word, O LORD, is it stands firm in the heavens”
(Psalms 119:89); “Do not add to his words, or He will
rebuke you and prove you a liar” (Proverbs 30:6);
- “The grass withers and the flowers fall, but the
word of our God stands forever" (Isaiah 40:7);
- "For assuredly, I say to you, till heaven and earth
pass away, one jot or one tittle will by no means pass from
the law till all is fulfilled” (Matthew 5:18);
- "I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear,
not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen,
will by any means disappear from the Law until everything
is accomplished” (Matthew 24:35);
- “I warn everyone who hears the words of the prophecy
of this book: If anyone adds anything to them, God will
add to him the plagues described in this book.” (Revelations
- "Whatever I command you, be careful to observe it;
you shall not add to it nor take away from it” (Deuteronomy
- "Do not let this Book of the Law depart from your
mouth; meditate on it day and night, so that you may be
careful to do everything written in it...” (Joshua
6. Does the Quran contradict itself when it authenticates
the biblical infallibility from the following references?
- “We gave the children of Israel the Scripture and
the Command and the Prophethood” (45:16);
- “We verily gave Moses the Scripture; so be not ye
in doubt of his receiving it; and we appointed it guidance
for the Children of Israel” 32:23);
- “We caused Jesus, son of Mary, confirming that which
was revealed before Him, and we bestowed on Him the Gospel,
wherein is guidance and a light, confirming which was revealed
before it in the Torah, a guidance and admonition”
7. Why does the Quran admonish Muslims who are in doubt
to approach both Christians and Jews for assurance and guidance?
Does the Quran ask Muslims to trust a Scripture that has
been changed? We read: “And if thou art in doubt concerning
that which We revealed unto thee, then question those who
read the Scripture before thee” (10:94).
No one with a clear conscience can attest to the fact that
the Bible has been changed. History provides no evidence,
nor even the Muslim sacred book. Muslims must come to the
Bible, read it, understand it, and see what it says about
God, man and salvation.
Fourth, the belief in Prophets. Muslims believe that Allah
has sent over 120,000 prophets for humankind across the
millennia of history. This number is taken from a Hadith
(saying) by Muhammad, but no one can identify them. However,
some of these prophets include names from the Bible, such
as Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad who is
called the “Seal of the Prophets.”
Several of the accounts found in the Quran about these major
prophets parallel the biblical narratives. Nevertheless
a cursory reading of the Quran reveals significant serious
reconstruction and historical questions. Some of these will
be discussed in the section: Questions about the Quran.
Fifth, belief in the Day of Judgment.
There are some similarities and discontinuities between
Islam and Christianity about eschatology in general and
the Day of Judgment in particular. The Quran emphasizes
the idea of resurrection of the body and the final judgment
where the wicked will be consigned to eternal hell fire,
while the believers will receive their final reward in Paradise.
The Day of Judgment will be preceded by great cosmic conflicts
similar to those described in the Book of Revelation. The
“Al-Dajjal” (Antichrist)will appear and will
cause much devastation and moral corruption. Afterwards
the “Mahdi” (guided one) will appear to bring
justice and will bring wealth and peace. This “Mahdi,”
however, is believed to be Jesus Christ, who will descend
(some say in Damascus, while others in Palestine) to kill
the Antichrist and judge the non-Muslims.
To interject some critical discontinuities between Islam
and Christianity concerning the Day of Judgment is important
for our discussion. The basis on which people are judged
in Islam in the final day is anchored in personal merit.
In the day of reckoning, evil and good deeds of persons
are placed on a scale. The greater override the lesser and
determine the person’s “kismet” (fate),
either in eternal heaven or eternal hell.
In his clash with the Pharisees, Jesus, however, warned
against trying to gain merits by self-righteousness. In
comparison, the Pharisees, who were the orthodox core of
Judaism, laid excessive emphasis on external piety. Their
adherence to the meticulous details of the letter of the
law and their reverence for tradition became the basis for
morality, spirituality and final salvation. Jesus, however,
insisted that "For out of the heart come evil thoughts”
(Matt. 15:19). The final judgment is based upon the fact
that the holy and just God must punish sin; therefore, sinners
must face the penalty. For those who trusted in Christ,
the sinless Son of God who took upon Himself the penalty
due us are saved from God’s judgment. Therefore, the
final judgment is determined on the basis of the person’s
relationship to Jesus Christ. God is just and the one who
justifies those who have faith in Jesus” (Romans 3:21-26).
Thus, the ground on which God judges the person is by faith
alone in Christ alone.
Another discontinuity with the Muslim concept of paradise
is found in the fact that paradise in Islam is described
in sensual and physical terms. The Quran is replete with
descriptive details about pleasures awaiting the believers
in Paradise. This include beautiful virgin women, fruit,
drink and meat, heart’s desires, dishes and goblets
of gold, and wine (Quran chapters 37; 56; 74; 83).
In contrast, the Bible speaks of heaven as the eternal
abode of the Triune God. It is a holy place and the perfect
experience of God’s people enjoying full fellowship
with Him and seeing Him face to face (Rev. 22:4). It is
a place of utter beauty prepared for those who love God,
“No eye has seen,no ear has heard,no mind has conceived
what God has prepared for those who love him” (I Cor.
2:9); It is a place of holiness, love, joy and eternal praises
and service to God the Father, God the Son and God the Holy
Spirit (Is. 35:8; I Cor. 13:13; Heb. 12:2; Rev. 22:3).
What are the Religious Duties Required by Muslims?
The religious obligations are five. They are identified
as “Arkan” (pillars or foundations):
1. “Shihadah” (Profession). “There is
no god except Allah and Muhammad is the messenger of Allah.”
2. “Salat” (prayer). Regular practice of five
3. “Zakat” Charitable giving.
4. “Hajj” (Pilgrimage)to Mecca.
5.”Sawm” (fasting) during the month of Ramadan
according to Muslim calendar.
Antithetically, the central and most distinctive aspect
of the Gospel is that salvation comes through Christ Jesus,
who offers His own life as substitute for the guilty. His
death made eternal life possible. The guilt of those who
trust in Him is removed, and they are adopted into God’s
family as “heirs of God and co-heirs with Christ,”
(Rom 8:17). Not so in Islam. Islam is a religion of law
and acts to its very core. The five duties become the road
of Muslim salvation. Orthodox Muslims structure their lives
around them according to a series of dos and don’ts
by rigidly revering and adhering to the traditions and the
law. The Pharisees are very much analogous to Muslims. They
were captivated by the tyranny of a legalistic commitment.
They were convinced that the ceremonial law and the tradition
of the elders were meritorious and the only way to righteousness.
Jesus called them blind (Matthew 23). Because of their infused
man-made morality that had conditioned their hearts, their
misinformed conscience excused their actions even in harassing
and plotting to kill the Lord. If they were sincere, they
were sincerely wrong. Their moral dilemma, which they did
not recognize, was that instead of allowing their guilt
to drive them to God, they rebelled against Him. Paul, after
being dramatically delivered from the encumbrance of legalism,
recognized that works righteousness is a denial of justification
by grace through faith in Jesus Christ alone. His letter
to the Galatians warns against the danger of the Judaizers’
teaching, which is based on legalism. In responding to such
teaching, the Apostle Paul insisted that a man is justified
only through faith on the basis of Christ’s finished
work (2:1-10). His message aroused a vehement opposition.
Paul called his opponent’s teaching (which they claimed
to be superior to the Gospel of Jesus) “turning to
a different gospel— which is really no gospel at all”
What is the Quran?
The Quran is the sacred book of Islam. Quran is an Arabic
name which means “reading or recitation.” It
contains what Muhammad claims to be the final disclosure
of Allah’s revelation given audibly and verbatim in
the Arabic language via the angel Gabriel. Muhammad claims
to have begun receiving these revelations when he was forty
years of age continually over a period of twenty three years
till his death in 632AD. Muhammad was a contemplative man,
often retreating to a cave on mount Hira near Mecca. While
in a state of trance he heard a voice commanding him to
read, notwithstanding the fact that he was illiterate. However,
Muslims claim Muhammad’s being miraculously enabled
to read and recite is an authentication of the revelation
and his prophethood. Moreover, Muslims believe that Muhammad
had nothing to do with the actual composition of the Quran;
he was only an instrument or mere conduit through which
Gabriel transmitted to him a revelation from Allah in the
original Arabic language. The Quran is believed to be inscribed
in heaven on tablets which are eternally preserved. Other
names are given to the Quran, including, Al-Furkan, meaning
demarcates between right and wrong; Al-Huda, guidance.
What does the Quran Contain?
The Quran is roughly smaller than the New Testament. It
contains 114 Suras (chapters), revealed to Muhammad over
twenty years. Contrary to the Bible, the Quran is not arranged
logically or chronologically nor by theme or genre. The
Suras are arranged after the death of Muhammad according
to its length including a variety of themes, such as the
oneness of Allah, his wrath if he is not heeded, stories
analogous to the Old and New Testament narratives, laws
and regulations about a variety of religious and social
As we mentioned earlier, the overwhelming majority of the
Quranic accounts, including creation, prophets, and elements
of faith, have their antecedents in the Bible and rabbinic
traditions. However, a cursory reading of the Quran reveals
significant reconstruction of some of these accounts. Not
only does the Quran incorporate most of its content from
the Bible, but it acknowledges its authority by recognizing
the “Turat” (first five books of Moses); the
“Zabur” (book of Psalms) and the “Injil”
The Gospel of Jesus).
Questions about the Quran
I appreciate the fact that the majority of Muslims are sincere
about protecting the Quran, believing it to be the inerrant
revelation from Allah. However, as I read the Quran, and
gleaned from other scholar’s-both Muslims and none-Muslims
analysis of it, I found that there are a number of critical
inquires which demand forthright answers by Muslim scholars.
Here are recapitulations of some of these questions:
How can both the Quran and Allah be eternal?
Muslims hold that the Arabic Quran is the exact replica
of a prototype of eternally preserved tablets in heaven.
These tablets however, were communicated verbatim to the
prophet Muhammad (Quran 43:3; 85:21-22; 56:76-77).
The view that the Quran is divine and is the very words
of Allah has produced a controversy among Muslim scholars.
The Muslim scholar Faruky explains:
“... the controversy that raged under Ma'mun [Abbasid
Caliph who reigned from 813-833], when he appointed Ibn
Abu Daud as chief justice. That jurist belonged to the Mutazilah
school, which held the Quran to be the created word of God
because it feared that the contrary (namely that the Quran
is the eternal word of God) would compromise the divine
unity. Ibn Abu Daud used his position to promote his view,
and he was opposed by Ahmad Ibn Hanbal who led a popular
resistance against the Mutazilah position. The opposing
populace correctly perceived that to declare the Quran created
is to subject it to space and time and all the conditioning
of history, to divest it of its holiness and thus to liberate
the Muslim consciousness from its determining power and
normativeness. The upshot was the downfall of the Mutazilah
School and repudiation of its doctrine. The Quran emerged
victorious, and the masses accepted it as uncreated not
only in its meaning or content but also in its form, in
the Arabic words in which it is composed” (Ismail,
Faruky 1986. Cultural Atlas of Islam. NY: MacMillan Publishing
Perhaps the dispute was settled, but the dilemma is
not. Certain questions must be asked:
- How can we allege that two eternalities exist together-one
is material in nature (i.e. Quran written on tablets 85:21-22),
and the other is spiritual (i.e. Allah)?
- How can we account for such dualism? How can a material
object exist coeternally with Allah without being created
- Does this mean that the Quran exists independently without
being contingent upon Allah? If this is the case, then we
must conclude that Islam teaches that matter is eternal.
- Can we conclude then that Islam is congruent, or at least
in part, with the Greek ideas or the theory of evolution
that matter is the basic stuff or raw material from which
every thing else is composed?
- Why can Islam allow these two eternalities to exist side
by side while opposing the biblical teaching of the eternal
tri-unity or tripersonal God who is one, existing in three
Persons-Father, Son and Holy Spirit equal in essence and
glory? Is not this Triunity much more cogent than the two
These question, and others demand answers and will continue
to hound the Muslim claims about the Quran.
Who are the Caliphs?
The “Caliph” is the title for the main leader
of the Muslim community. It literally means to leave behind
a successor or viceregent. The title is given to the successor
of Muhammad who is vested with absolute authority of the
laws of the Quran and Sunnah. The first four Caliphs are
called the companions of the prophet. After Muhammad’s
death, Abu Bakr (632-634), the first to accept Islam, was
elected as the first Caliph. After two years he was succeeded
by Umar (634-644). Umar succeeded in spreading Islam in
most of the Middle East, including Arabia, Iraq, Persia,
Syria, Persia and Egypt. Umar was replaced by Uthman (644-656),
who governed for some twelve years during the peak of the
Islamic expansion into Armenia, Cyprus and north Africa.
With the death of the prophet and several key reciters during
the battles, The Caliph Uthman greatly feared the loss of
the original text-or, as some believe, what was left of
the oral tradition. Uthman commissioned a group under the
leadership of Zayed Ben Thabit to produce an official written
A series of uprisings began during Uthman’s rule,
and a new period of schisms and civil wars started with
his murder. He was succeeded by Ali (656-661), who was the
cousin and son-in-law of the prophet Muhammad. He became
the fourth and last of what is called ”Al-khulafa
al-Rashidoon” (the Rightly Guided Caliphs). Ali inherited
the political and religious implications of Uthman’s
murder. After a series of civil rebellions, Ali was killed
with a poisoned sword by a member of the Kharijite sect
(dissenters), which had seceded from Ali’s ranks.
What areas did Muslims conquer?
Following the example of Muhammad and the Quranic injunctions,
Muslim armies continued to conquer and subjugate subjects
in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia. The East Roman Empire,
called the Byzantine, was plagued with constant political,
social, and religious strife. It came under relentless attack
by the invading Muslim armies in the year 636 A.D., and
the Christian church has never recovered. Within a century,
the Islamic armies had subjugated Saudi Arabia, the entire
Middle East, Central Asia, and large parts of India.
The Muslim forces continued their advance into North Africa
and Spain. In 711 A.D., under the leadership of Tariq Ben
Ziad, 7000 Berbers and 300 Arabs crossed the Straits of
Gibralter into Spain. Soon after, Mousa Ben Nusayer, Arab
governor of North Africa, crossed with 10,000 Arabs and
8000 Berbers. While the forces of the Spanish king were
distracted by a rebellion in the north, the Muslim army
swiftly conquered Spain and Portugal.
After their success in Spain, they invaded France hoping
to capture all of southern Europe and Constantinople, which
they failed to conquer during their invasion earlier from
the east. The Caliphs of Damascus hoped to control the whole
Mediterranean Sea and make it an Arab lake. Muslim armies
advanced in France and were 125 miles from Paris when they
were defeated at the Battle of Tours in the year 732 A.D.
by European forces led by Charles Martel. One of the most
critical battles in history, the victory at Tours would
determine the future faith of Europe.
However, Muslim armies from the east tried again to control
all of Europe later. The Turks, under Muhammad II, conquered
Constantinople in 1453 and made it an Ottoman capital. Under
Sulayman (the Magnificent), much of the Balkan Peninsula,
Hungry, Greece, Yugoslavia, Bulgaria came under Ottoman
control. By 1685 they had reached Vienna, where, once again,
the Western forces defeated the advancing Ottoman Muslim
What is the Jihad and how did Muhammad spread Islam?
Muhammad was a man who was consumed by a deep sense of “dawah,”
which means in an Islamic context “to propagate the
faith by calling people to embrace Islam.” His unquenchable
zeal for spreading Islam has left a lasting influence upon
Among the many uses of the term “dawah” in
the Quran, perhaps the most potent and far-reaching implication
is its use in connection with the external mission of Islamic
propagation, that is the concept of Jihad (Quran 8:74,75
9:44). From the beginning, “dawah” has been
associated with military conquest, the justification for
which is laid down in the Quranic prescriptions: (2:69;
2:190; 2:217; 2:256; 3:103; 8:39; 8:61-62; 25:52; 61:9).
Thus, the importance of the propagation of Islam has been
ingrained since its beginning in the consciousness of Muslims.
Resulting from its connection with the divine imperative
in the Quran, it was inspired by the actions of the prophet
and stirred by his call for “jihad fe sabeel Allah”
(struggle in the path of Allah). The idea of martyrdom (shihadah)
and the use of the sword as well as the word were therefore
not a matter of choice but part and parcel of the way of
life for devout Muslims. The Hadith tells us that Muhammad’s
own soul yearned for martyrdom for the cause of Islam. Abu
Hurrairah, a companion of the prophet and respected traditionalist
I heard the prophet say: “I would not remain behind
an army that fights in the way of Allah. . . . I love that
I should be killed in the way of Allah then brought to life,
then killed again, then brought to life, then killed again.”
(Ali 1977, 261-62)
Another explicit reference to the idea of armed struggle
points to the way in which Muhammad’s thoughts and
commands continued to be the normative standard at least
in the early period of Islam. It is reported in the traditions
of Muhammad by Ibn Umar:
I have been commanded that I should fight these people [non-Muslims]
till they bear witness that there is no god but Allah and
keep up the prayer and pay Zakat. When they do this, their
blood and their property shall be safe with me except as
Islam requires, and their reckoning is with Allah. (Ali
It would be difficult for a Muslim scholar to reconcile
the idea of Jihad with the Quranic command, “There
is no compulsion in religion” (Surah 2:190). Today,
the idea of Jihad as pertaining to the physical struggle
against the enemies of Islam is an acceptable norm among
the increasing number of fundamentalists who are actively
calling for the "return to usuliyah" (back to
the roots). For more on this see the question: “What
is modern day Islamic fundamentalism and how does it influence
Who are the People of the Book?
The Quran refers to both Jews and Christians as “Ahl-al-kitab”
(the people of the book). The testimony of the Quran itself
points to the significant role that Judaism and Christianity
played in the formation of Islam. From the Quran's own record
Surely, we sent down the Torah full of guidance and light
(Surah 5:45). We caused Jesus, son of Mary, to follow in
their footsteps, fulfilling that which was revealed before
him in the Torah, and we gave him the Gospel which is guidance
and light, fulfilling that which was revealed before it
in the Torah, and a guidance and admonition for the righteous.
The incongruity is that the Quran clearly testifies to
the validity and authority of both the Torah and the Gospel,
while at the same time it charges both the Jews and the
Christians of corrupting their own Scriptures, thus invalidating
them (Quran 2:75,101; 3:70,78,187; 4:46). It suffices to
say here that Muslim scholars have not provided any proof
to justify this claim.
What is the Kaaba?
The Kaaba is the center of the Mslim world and the most
sacred pilgrimage shrine called "Haram". It is
rather a small windowless cube-shaped structure located
in the center of the Grand Mosque in Mecca. It is about
12 meters long, 10 meters wide, and 15 meters high. It was
built to enclose the "al-Hajar al-Aswad" (Black
Stone), the most venerated object in Islam. Probably of
meteoric origin, the stone is traditionally believed to
have been given to Adam on his fall from paradise. The stone
was originally white but has become black by absorbing the
sins of the thousands of pilgrims who have kissed and touched
it. Some questions Muslims extreme veneration of the stone.
Muslim, however, try to explain that the Black Stone is
not worshipped and not considered holy in itself. Muslims
believe that the Kaaba is built directly under the throne
of Allah. I am not sure how this belief can be defensible
knowing that the earth shaped as a globe, and its center
can be at any point. Moreover, the earth is constantly at
motion tilting around its own axis and orbiting the Sun.
The Black Stone is set in gold and attached on the eastern
corner of Kaaba. Muslim legends says that Kaaba was erected
by Adam; and according to the Quran it was rebuild later
by Abraham after the Flood (2:127-128).
The Kaaba becomes the prayer direction (Ar. qiblah) toward
which Muslims around the world bow in prayer to Allah. The
Kaaba and all the city of Mecca is sacred territory reserved
only for Muslims; all other people are forbidden to enter.
The pilgrimage (Ar. hajj) to Mecca, is one of the basic
tenets of Islam.
The circling of the Kaaba is called "tawaf."
This performance includes seven circuits performed around
Kaaba. Each circuit is called a "Shawt;" seven
"Shawts" make one "Tawaf." This circumambulate
must be performed by all Pilgrims according to specifice
rules including the kissing of the black Stone.
Why do Muslims visit Mecca?
The Quran demands of every able Muslim to make the pilgrimage
to Mecca (Hajj) at least once in a lifetime. In Surah 3:97
we read: "Wherein are plain memorials; the place where
Abraham stood up to pray; and whosoever entereth it is safe.
And Pilgrimage to the house is a duty unto Allah for mankind,
for him who can find a way thither,” This duty is
considered part of the Five Pillars of Islam. Unlike the
Gospel, these Pillars, including the Hajj, provide all the
necessary works in order to secure salvation. The Hajj consists
basically of the following beliefs and rituals:
1- From the above mentioned Quranic verse, Muslims traditionally
trace this ritual back to Abraham. They maintain that Abraham
brought his son Ishmael in order to sacrifice him to Allah
rebuild Al-Kaaba (Quran 3:127). Muhammad reclaimed this
shrine from pagans and converted it to a Muslim site that
becomes the most sacred place on Earth for Muslims.
What does the Bible Say? "God tested Abraham. He said
to him, "Abraham!... Take your son your only son, Isaac,
whom you love, ang go to the region of Moriah. Sacrifice
him there as a burnt offering." (Gen. 22:1-2).
2. The pilgrimage to Mecca is performed once a year, during
the last Islamic lunar calander. It is considered the highest
personal religious achievement. Some Muslims consider it
as a form of personal rebirth whereby one can devout himself
unequivocally to Allah and the religion of Islam.
What does the Bible Say? In John chapter four, the Samaritan
woman told Jesus: "Our fathers worshiped on this mountain,
but you Jews claim that the place where we must worship
is in Jerusalem." After all, this mountain, Gerizim,
had a significant role in the tradition of the Samaritan.
Here Abraham prepared the sacrifice of Isaac, and in their
Scripture Gerizim is the mountain on which the altar was
erected. Nonetheless, Jesus' answer was unmistakable:
Believe me woman, a time is comingwhen you will worship
the Father neither on this mountain nor in Jerusalem...
a time is coming and has now come when the true worshiper
will worship the Father in Spirit and truth, for they are
the kind of worshipers the Father seeks. God is spirit,
and his worshipers must worship in Spirit and in truth (John
3- The Hajj commences by the performance of the ritual
of outward physical purification followed by wearing of
a white garments.
What does the Bible Say? Though it is not wise to judge
the motive of individual Muslims engaging in acts of worship,
but we need to see what Jesus has to say. Jesus gave a stern
warning to the Pharisees who were meticulous about the minute
details of outward acts of worship and purification:
Woe to you, teachers of the law and Pharisees, you hypocrites!
You clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside they
are full of greed and self-indulgence. Blind Pharisee! First
clean the inside of the cup and dish, and then the outside
also will be clean (Matt 23:25).
4- After achieving the state of cleanliness, the pilgrims
are ready to enter Mecca and begin what is called the "Umra"
(secondary Hajj). This initiatory ritual involves "tawaf"
circumambulating the Kaaba.
What does the Bible Say? The idea of true cleanliness and
perfection of the heart corresponds with the idea of clearing
the conscience from guilt associated with outward piety
instead of genuine righteousness from the heart of worshiper.
In Hebrews 10:22 we read: "let us draw near to God
with a sincere heart in full assurance of faith, having
our hearts sprinkled to cleanse us from a guilty conscience."
Furthermore, the writer of Hebrews maintains that guilt
cannot be expunged by the performance of good works or obedience
to the law:
... gifts and sacrifices being offered were not able to
clear the conscience of the worshiper. They are only a matter
of food and drink and various ceremonial washings--external
regulations applying until the time of the new order. (Heb.
5- Closely connected with "Umra" is the ritual
of running between the two hills sorrounding al-Kaaba recalling
the despairing Abraham's wife Hagar in search for water.
The pilgrims travel to the two mountains, "Marwah"
and "Safa" near Mecca where Muslims believe that
Hagar searched for water at this location as she left her
son Ishmael and hastened between the two mountains in a
desperate hunt for water. When she returned to her child,
the angel Gabriel appeared and led her to a spring of water
called the well of "Zamzam". In similar fashion,
Muslim pilgrims run between the two mountains. Then they
visit the Zamzam well, where many purchase from this precious
water to take home.
What does the Bible Say? The book of Genesis says that
Hagar was with Ishamael in Beersheba south of Palastine
and both lived in Paran-modern day Sinai in Egypt (Gen 21:14,21).
6. The main pilgrimage begins by the critical ritual of
"Wuquf" (Standing) with extreme seriousness. The
obligation of standing before Allah in a position of prayer
takes place in the barren plain of Arafat about fifteen
Miles from Mecca. Any improper performance of this standing
invalidates the entire pilgrimage.
People have a tendency to do something in order to earn
the sanction of the conscience, and we often condemn ourselves
when we fall short. The Book of Hebrews gives concrete teaching
that we can never satisfy the demand of conscience through
self-expiation (Heb. 9:9-10).
7. On the road back to Mecca, pilgrims find a pebbles for
tossing at three pillars-located nearby area, sympolizing
stoning of the devil while chanting "God is great."
8. The ritual sacrificing of animals follows. This ceremony
commemorates Abraha's sacrifice of a ram to Allah instead
of Ishmael. The title given to Ishmael is ‘Abu-al-fida’
(father of the ransom). It reflects the traditional Islamic
belief that it was Ishmael who was to be sacrificed, not
Isaac, contrary to the Biblical narrative. Nonetheless,
all pilgrims are required to offer an animal sacrifice.
Both acts of sacrifice and the subsequent feast last for
thee days and coincides with the same celebration by Muslims
world-wide. This feast is called the "Greater Feast"
while the other feast at the end of the fasing of Ram,adan
is called "the Lesse Feast."
What does the Bible Say?
In the introduction to his commentary, The Epistle to the
Hebrews, F. F. Bruce points out:
The Aaronic priests offered up sacrifices repeatedly, and
our author pays particular attention to the annual sin-offering
presented on the nation’s behalf by the high priest
on the day of atonement. But the animal sacrifice could
not meet the real need of men and women. A sin-stained conscience
is a barrier to communion with God, and the cleansing of
the conscience could not be effected by such sacrifice as
the levitical cultus provided. But Christ exercises His
priestly ministry on the basis of a real and efficacious
sacrifice— “the sacrifice of himself”
(Heb. 9:26). The nature of this sacrifice our author finds
expressed in the language of Ps. 40:6-8, where someone who
knows the uselessness of animal sacrifices dedicated his
life to God for the obedient accomplishment of His will
(Bruce 1964, 54).
Again, the Book of Hebrews gives concrete teaching that
we can never satisfy the demand of conscience through self-expiation.
It can be accomplished only through the efficacy of Christ’s
sacrifice, which provides the ground for justification.
9. Following the sacrifice, the pilgrims often shave their
heads signifying the completion of the the Hajj and return
to Al-Kaaba for another "tawaf" circumambulation
and stonning of the devil.
10- As the pilgrims return home they leave with the satisfaction
of gaining merits with Allah. Furthermore, they acquire
a new religious and social status culminating by the title
"Hajji" for a male and "Hajjiah" for
a female. They are treated as ideal Muslims worthy of respect
What is “Dar al-Islam” and Dar al-Harb?
According to Islamic traditions, the globe is divided into
two domains: “Dar al-Islam” (abode/House of
Islam) and “Dar al-Harb (Abode/House of War). Dar
al-Islam is an Arabic term means more precisely, those territories
controlled by the Islamic religion where the Shariah (Islamic
Law) prevails. Non-Muslims may live there, nonetheless,
they are considered as part of the domain of war (some times
called “Dar al-Kufr” (Domain of Unbelief/infidels)
Historically the domain/house of war is understood by orthodox
Muslims as the foreign world which has not yet come under
the majority rule of Islam. Nonetheless, the more militant
and fundamentalist Muslims reject all non-Muslim ethos.
They appeal to the Quran for inscribing Islamic universal
values even if it takes military actions against Dar al-Harb.
How about Abraham?
"All the children of Abraham deserve peace." Thus
spake U.S. President George W. Bush in a pronouncement on
the White House lawn earlier this year. His biblical reference
highlighted one core element of the agonizing and tragic
dilemma that has stymied Middle East peacemakers: Arabs
and Jews both claim Abraham as their ancestor.
Both Arabs and Jews claimed Abraham as their forefather.
The Torah says ‘Abraham is ours; he is our father’
the father of Isaac and Jacob maintain the Jews. They emphasize
what they see as divine given entitlement including land
and national identity through Abraham. Abraham for the Jewish
people is the most revered patriarch, and they are reluctant
to share him with others. Raphael Patai says:
“One of the most tenacious popular beliefs transmitted
from generation to generation of Jews is that of Abrahamic
descent... this popular Jewish belief has become a psychological
fact holding the Jews together. The image of “Abraham
our Father” has been focal in Jewish consciousness
throughout history.” (The Jewish Mind 1977)
Moreover, Jews claim that God promised Abraham and his descendants
a land from the river of Egypt to the great river Euphrates”
Jews were not the only people who maintained to be the true
descendants of Abraham. Muslims also maintain that Ibrahim
(Abraham) is the first ‘Hanif’ (monotheist Muslim).
Moreover, he is the father of Ismail (Ishmael), the progenitor
of the Arab race including the prophet Muhammad. Muslims
also came to heighten their claim as descendants from the
Patriarch. The Quran incorporates several events in the
life of Abraham similar to those found in the Bible. Nevertheless,
a number of narratives are added in the Quran , such as
Abraham's travel to Mecca with his son Ishmael and building
the Kaaba (Quran 2: 125-127); quarrels with idol worshipers
(Quran 21:51-57); argues with his father (Azar) against
idolatry (Quran 6:74). It is important to keep in mind that
Muhammad's skillful borrowing-in the process of the formation
of Islam, from previous traditions later became the heart
and soul of the new faith. It is striking however, that
Muhammad's appeal to previous revelation (i.e., Torah; Psalms
and Injil (Gospel), was ignored or rejected when he understood
them to be incompatible with the accounts found in the Quran.
Anyway, Abraham is called Hanif (i.e. monotheist Muslim).
The Quran reads: “And they say: Be Jews or Christians,
then you will be rightly guided. Say: Nay, but (we follow)
the religion of Abraham, the upright, and he was not of
the idolaters” (2:135).
Nonetheless, any claim of Abraham’s ownership must
be qualified, says the Lord Jesus Christ. There is a strong
propensity among Jews and Muslims to interpret their Abrahamic
connection in religious, political and racial terms.
It is apparent that Both Jews and Muslims have laid claim
to Abraham. These claims including both conflicts and points
Where did the confusion about the Trinity in Islam
Muhammad’s charge against pre-Islamic religious groups
contributed to his misconception of the Christian idea of
the Trinity and Christ’s being called the Son of God.
We read in the Quran: “They surely disbelieve who
say: Lo Allah is the third of three; when there is no God
save the one God" (5:73). Another verse says: “And
they say: Allah hath taken unto Himself a Son... Nay, but
whatsoever is in the heaven and the earth is His. All are
subservient unto Him” (2:116). In fact Muhammad’s
charge was not directed against orthodox Christianity, but
against some heretical groups existing in Arabia prior to
Islam. Muhammad had to deal with the Jews and the Christians,
including the Nestorians, the Jacobites, the Copts, the
Melkites and others. It is unfortunate that such an arrant
misunderstanding of the authentic Christianity continues
to plague the mind and conscience of Muslims around the
world as they are taught from early childhood.
Among the most important pre-Islamic deities were the al-Manat;
al-Lat and the al-Uzza. These three are also mentioned in
the Quran and referred to as "the daughters of Allah."
The al-Manat was an ancient Semite goddess. The etymological
derivation is perhaps connected with the Aramaic m’nata
(portion or lot). The Arabic word "Manaya", came
to mean “fate” and was associated with the concept
of death. She was a prominent goddess among the many deities,
and a popular sanctuary was erected for her near Mecca.
Al-Lat was another venerated Arabian goddess. Most philologists
derive the name from the form (al-ilahat), which means “the
deities.” Her sanctuary was located at the valley
of Wadiji near the town of Taif in Arabia.
Al-Uzza is the third goddess in the pre-Islamic Arab pantheon.
She was principally an important idol associated with the
tribe of Khata-fan, but later her worship spread over to
the main tribes including the tribe of Quraysh (the tribe
of Muhammad). The historical significance of al-Uzza and
the exact meaning of the name is uncertain among the Arabs.
However, it has been suggested by some that Uzza should
be identified with the Queen of the Heavens (cf. Jer. 7:18).
Recognizing the deep attachment of the Arabian tribes to
their deities caused Muhammad to compromise. Afraid of causing
opposition to his message and division among the tribes,
he went so far as to recognize the pre-Islamic pagan trinity
(al-Lat, al-Uzza, and al-Manat) as mediators with Allah.
This reinforced the prevalent idea that the members of this
trinity were, in fact, the "daughters of Allah."
However, Muhammad later retracted this position.
Thus in Quran 3:9 we read, “What think ye, then,
of al-Lat and al-Uzza, Manat, the third idol besides?"
In connection with this verse, Thomas Hughes, in his dictionary
of Islam, relates the following interesting discussion between
Muhammad, the idol worshipers, Satan, and Gabriel. Al-Tabari,
a famed Arab historian and scholar born AD 839 relates that,
... on a certain day, the chief men of Mecca, discussed
the affairs of the city, when the prophet [Muhammad] appeared,
and seating himself by them in a friendly manner, began
to recite the 53rd chapter of the Quran ; and when he had
reached the verse: "What think ye then of al-Lat, and
al-Uzza and Manat, the third idol besides?" the devil
suggested words of reconciliation and compromise with idolatry,
namely, "these are exalted females and verily their
intercession is to be hoped for." These words, however,
which were received by the idolaters with great delight,
were afterwards disavowed by the prophet, for Gabriel revealed
to him the true reading, namely, "What think ye then
of al-Lat, and al-Uzza and Manat, the third idol besides?
Shall ye have male progeny and make God female? This, then,
was an unjust partition! Verily, these are mere names which
ye and your fathers have given them."
One can argue persuasively that Muhammad was perplexed
about the difference between tritheism of pre-Islam and
the true concept of the Trinity. Muhammad’s charge
was directed first of all against the polytheism of pre-Islam.
Later, however, his charge against pre-Islamic religious
groups contributed to Muhammad's misconception of the Christian
idea of the Trinity and Christ’s being called the
Son of God. We read in the Quran: “They surely disbelieve
who say: Lo Allah is the third of three; when there is no
God save the one God" (5:73). Another verse says: “And
they say: Allah hath taken unto Himself a Son. . . . Nay,
but whatsoever is in the heaven and the earth is His. All
are subservient unto Him” (2:116). In fact Muhammad’s
charge was not directed against orthodox Christianity, but
against some heretical Christian groups existing in Arabia
prior to Islam. Muhammad had to deal with the Jews and the
Christians including the Nestorians, the Jacobites, the
Copts, the Melkites and others. It is unfortunate that such
an arrant misunderstanding of the authentic Christianity
continues to plague the mind and conscience of Muslims around
the world as they are taught from early childhood.
What about the crusades?
The crusade wars undertaken between 11th and 13th Centuries
were a complex drama in the history of the church and its
relation with Islam. Historians tells us that, although
the Crusaders had economic and political reasons for fighting,
the primary reason by which the church justifies the wars
of the Crusades was religious. The immediate threat by Muslims
was felt at home by the Western Church several centuries
prior to the crusades, when the Muslim armies invaded Spain
in 711 and endangered the very existence of the Church in
western Europe. The Fatimid in Egypt, as we mentioned above,
ruled the Holy land during the brutal reign of Al-Hakim,
the neurotic Caliph of Egypt who destroyed the Church of
the Nativity and curtailed the freedom of worship for the
Christians in the Holy Land. While other Caliphs were relatively
more tolerant, Al-Hakim now threatened the very life of
Middle Eastern Christianity, which traces its roots to the
Christ of Bethlehem and the Early Apostolic Church.
The first Crusades (1095-99) accomplished their goal by
recapturing Jerusalem. However, by the end of the second
Crusade (1147-49 A.D.), the celebrated Muslim general Saladin
embarked on a jihad that managed to recapture Jerusalem.
In 1187 A.D., a Third Crusade was led by King Richard of
England. The Christians won some battles, but Saladin was
able to cling to Jerusalem. Finally, both nemesis negotiated
a truce that allowed the Muslims control the Holy Lands,
but Christians were free to visit their shrines.
What were the results of the Crusades?
The goal of the crusading wars was mainly religious-to free
the Holy land, to restore freedom of worship, and to provide
a safe environment for pilgrimages to the Christian sites.
Moreover, the Popes hoped also to extinguish all dissensions
and divisions in Christendom, East and West. However, with
the defeat of the Crusaders after 200 years of wars, this
goal was not achieved.
How should we think about the Crusades today?
The term “Crusades” is widely used, abused,
and misunderstood today. When President Bush used the term
“Crusades,” pointing to the moral duty to fight
the evil of terrorism, he was criticized by both the media
here and several Muslim nations. They alleged that such
a usage evokes in the minds of Muslims negative memories
associated historically with the term. Osama bin Laden declared
war against the "Jews and the Crusaders;” Campus
Crusade for Christ uses the same term as they endeavor to
spread the Good News-the message of God’s Grace around
the world. Furthermore, the legacy of the Crusades still
lingers in the minds of Muslims, as they mistakenly associate
it with the core message of the Gospel. Some today are calling
Christians to apologize for the wars of the Crusades. How
to make sense of all of this?
Here are some questions for your considerations:
1. Are the Crusades a justified Christian holy war based
on biblical principles or an enterprise intimately connected
with that of the popes?
2. Are the Crusades justifiable based on the idea of defense
of the Christian ideal, plus the freedom and protection
of Christians from persecution?
3. Are the harshness and devastation characteristic of the
Crusades justified ?
4. Are Muslims correct by equating the Crusades with their
holy war (Jihad)?
5. Did the Church gain by the Crusades?
6. Did the Crusades have a permanent negative effect upon
Stephen Neill, perhaps the greatest modern day church historian,
gives us criteria by which we can encounter the issue of
We have already spoken of the tension between the dar-ul-Islam,
the world of Islam, and the Christian west, which has been
one of the dominant factors in world history for a thousand
years. There have been faults on both sides, and these we
can leave for the judgment of God. What is essential that
we should understand the dark shadow which has been cast
everywhere on the Muslim mind by the wanton aggressiveness
of the west. Like the Jew, the Muslim may forget his own
faults in the contemplation of ours; we may leave him to
this occupation, and welcome only the service that he has
rendered in calling our attention to our own. Memories are
long in the east. To us the Crusades are very ancient history;
to the Muslim they are as though they had happened yesterday.
(1984. Crises of Belief. London, Hodder and Stoughton, P.75).
How did Muslims react to Western Colonialism?
At the end of the Ottoman empire after WWI, most of the
Arab and Muslim lands fell in the hands of Western powers,
mostly French and British. The bulk of the Arab states resented
the Ottomans-though they were Muslims rulers - for their
ruthlessness, stagnation and lack of innovation. Suddenly,
they found themselves under other occupying colonial Western
powers that shared very little, if any, of their values
and way of life, and they could not do any thing about it.
This further subjugation of Muslims, fueled their frustration
and antagonism, though the colonial powers have contributed
to the advancement in learning and industry.
Additionally, the introduction of Western style schools,
vigorous Christian mission activities and proselytizing,
publications of Christian literature which questioned the
credibility of Islam, have augmented Muslim antipathy toward
Furthermore, while Muslims understood that the battle with
the new Western colonialism is fundamentally a battle of
values, they also saw colonialism as an imperialistic political
and economical undertaking.
Arabs during the colonial period resisted vehemently the
attempts of the colonialists to replace Arabic--the language
of their holy book--with the English or French language.
Islam and the Arabic language are two major foundations
maintaining a strong sense of Arab nationalism. They are
considered as two inseparable aspects of one thing.
In short, losing the once advanced civilization, particularly
in the Middle Ages, at the hands of the colonialists, has
contributed to Muslim estrangement toward Western powers
and antipathy to Christianity-which is associated inaccurately
with these powers. Such an attitude becomes a fixation and
prelude to the resurgence of modern day Islamic fundamentalism.
What is modern day Islamic fundamentalism and how
does it influence Muslims?
The Oxford Dictionary succinctly defines fundamentalism
as a:“Strict adherence to traditional orthodox tenets...
opposed to liberalism and modernism.” Such a definition
might apply to the Christian fundamental movement in our
modern day because it is basically characterized by religious
motives. Nonetheless, Islamic fundamentalism is far more
complex, for it enshrines a number of religious themes and
socio-political discontents, as we shall see in the following
historical brief sketch.
Perhaps the first vanguard of Islamic fundamentalism, and
still the most influential today, was Jamal Al-Din Al Afghani
(1838-1897). His call for the Pan-Islamic unity against
the imperial conquest of the West, particularly after the
Napoleonic invasion of Egypt in 1882, became very popular
among Muslims. He infused religious Islamic themes in his
political activism, appealing to the growing resentment
against foreign domination. He also called for overthrow
of rulers who are submissive to foreign power.
Another influential fundamentalist is Hasan Al-Banna (1906-1949).
He was influenced by Al Afghani’s thought. However,
he founded a new movement in Egypt, still in operation today,
named: “The Society of Muslim Brethren”, it
became the first modern strict and militant fundamentalist
movement. They engaged in a series of assassinations including
none-Muslims and Judges, plus an attempt on the life of
Egypt’s president, Jamal Abdul Nasser. Al-Banna himself
was killed, and Abdul Nasser suppressed the Society of Muslim
Brethren ruthlessly. They continued, however, to operate
in Egypt and other countries in the Middle East.
Another extremist and combative leader in Egypt was Sayyed
Qutb. After the death of Al-Banna, he assumed the leadership
role and succeeded in inspiring Islamic Jihad organizations
by revitalizing anti western sentiments. Violence at tourist
attractions in Egypt in recent years is an example of the
fundamentalist hostility to Westerners, while at the same
time an attempt to destabilize what they maintain as a secular
Another well known Fundamentalist who was the first successful
revolutionary is Ayatollah Khomeini (1902-1989). He emphasized
revolution to overthrow secular Islamic governments. His
seizure of the US embassy in Teheran and capture of American
hostages was an indication of his deep resentment to Western
values. He understood that the conflict with the West, led
by America, is more than political. It is rather religious
and cultural based on the idea that the Western powers represent
the real enemies of Islam.
After the 1967 Six Days War, a shameful defeat of Arabs
at the hands of Israel, Islamic fundamentalism flourished.
They turned defeat into their advantage. They were able
to move the masses by appealing to their history and deciphering
their frustration. Fundamentalists contended that the Arabs
had lost the war because they had lost their faith in Islam.
The real reason was secularism and departure from the true
Islam that characterizes most Arab regimes.
Fundamentalists are ardent in their emphasis that the Allah
of Islam is the Allah of absolute power. The very makeup
of Islam is power. They assert that the reason Islam has
lost its glory and power is because they have lost their
religious bearings. They insist that the only way of survival
is return to a system of beliefs based on the Islamic Shariah’
(law) as taught in the Quran and implemented by Muhammad.
For them, Islam supplies the only answer. Recapturing the
lost power and sense of history, necessitates true “Jihad”
based on total religious commitment and sacrifice, including
In short, Islamic fundamentalism, which is nourished by
appealing to the religious and socio-political sentiments
among Muslims, will remain a threat and continue to surge
forth unless real democratic reforms are established in
the Arab and Muslim World, the Arab-Israeli conflict is
resolved, and perhaps Islam is rethought in a new course,
as some Islamic thinkers are trying to do.
What is Wahabbism?
Al-Wahhabiyyah (Ar. for Wahhabism)is an unyielding Islamic
persuasion and revivalist movement began in Arabia by Muhammad
Ibn Abd al-Wahhab (1703-1792). He called for a strict interpretation
of Islamic theology and practice calling the community to
return to Islam as practiced by Muhammad a thousand years
earlier. When opposed by certain tribes, he allied himself
with the modern founder of Arabia, the tribal chief Muhammad
Ibn Saud. Both declared the Jihad to purify the land from
the infidels and unislamic practices. By the death of Abd
al-Wahhab in 1792 Wahabbis grew to be the dominant power
in Arabia and continues today in the hands of the Saudi
clan. While Wahhabism is not the dominant sect in the world-wide
Islam, nevertheless it exercises immense power in the world.
Saudi Arabia has more than one quarter of the world's oil
reserves. The oil industry not only dominates the local
economy, but unfortunately, influences the world economy
and foriegn policy- making of other countries.
As adherent to the Wahhabi fundamantalist strict sect,
Arabia leads the Open Doors World Watch List as the world's
worst country for persecuting Christians and abusing religious
liberty. Saudis makes no secret for such policies. On March
10, 2003, the Defense Minister Prince Sultan of Saudi Arabia
announced publically that Saudis Won't Allow Churches on
Its Land. The Associated Press Network reported:
Saudi Arabia, as the birthplace of Islam, will not allow
churches to be built on its land, according to Defense Minister
Prince Sultan. Islam is the only accepted religion in Saudi
Arabia, home to the faith's holiest shrines in Mecca and
Medina. "This country was the launch pad for the prophecy
and the message, and nothing can contradict this, even if
we lose our necks" (AP March 10, 2003 ).
Moreover, according to the US State Department's 2000 Annual
Report on International Religious Freedom, we read:
Freedom of Religion does not exist [in Saudi Arabia]. Islam
is the official religion, and all citizens must be Muslims.
The Government prohibits the public practice of other religions.
Private worship by non Muslims is permitted. The Government
has declared the Islamic holy book the Koran, and the Sunna
(tradition) of the Prophet Muhammad, to be the country's
Constitution. The Government bases its legitimacy on governance
according to the precepts of a rigorously conservative form
of Islam. Neither the Government nor society in general
accepts the concept of separation of religion and state.
Conversion by a Muslim to another religion is considered
apostasy. Public apostasy is a crime under Shariah (Islamic
law) and punishable by death. Islamic practice generally
is limited to that of the Wahabi order ... Apostasy is a
capital offence under the Sharia Islamic law, as when a
Muslim converts to another religion. (U.S. Department of
State Annual Report on International Religious Freedom for
Nothing has changed today. According to a number of human
right organizations, the persecutions, imprisonments and
deportations of any suspected practicing Christian is practiced
Among the modern day extreme Wahabbi followers who hold
a grotesque interpretations of religious values are Ben
Laden and the late Taliban who were originally not Wahabbis,
but later embraced Wahhabism.
How did Arabs react to the birth of the State of
In 1917 Chaim Weizmann (1874-1952), Zionist leader and first
president of Israel (1948-1952), was able to procure from
the British government, what is known as “Balfour
declaration.” It included a pro Zionist statement
for the establishment of a Jewish state in Palestine. After
World War I the “League of Nations ratified the declaration
and in 1922 appointed Britain to rule in Palestine. Thousands
of Jews began immigrating to Palestine particularly from
Germany escaping persecution.
The U.N. General assembly in 1947, passed the partition
plan of Palastine, creating a Jewish and a Palestinian homeland.
The religious Jewish leaders vehemently objected to the
partition, hoping to rule all Palestine, and later engaged
in a series of militant activities against the British and
Arabs, while Arabs in Palestine stepped-up violence against
On May 14, 1948, however, the interim government of Israel
announced the birth of the State of Israel. Arab nations
remained staunchly opposed to the declaration. The Land
of Milk and Honey became the land of militancy and hostilities.
On May 15, 1948, five Arab armies entered Israel and the
first Arab-Israeli war began. The Arab armies were composed
of nearly 80,000 men. Israel, however, mobilized a greater
number of well-trained fighters. The invading Arab armies
failed, and Israel gained more territories. After its victory,
Israel expected the Arabs to concede and accept its independence.
This did not happen till 1979 when President Anwar Sadat
of Egypt signed a peace treaty with Israel. Syria opposed
Sadat’s visit on the grounds that any lasting peace
with Israel should be comprehensive, including all concerned
parties. While time proved that this was a wise assessment,
nevertheless Sadat was eager to travel to Israel, leaving
other countries in a state of war with neighboring nemeses.
While Sadat become very popular in the international community,
he was opposed in the Arab world for a variety of reasons.
However, his bold and courageous stand led to his death
when a group of extremists Muslim brotherhood assassinated
him in 1981.
How people are converted in Islam?
The Muslim’s “Shihadah” (confession)says:
“There is no Allah except one Allah and Muhammad is
the messenger of Allah.” If a person believes such
a statement and vocalizes it before two Muslim witnesses,
he automatically becomes a Muslim.
Conversion, nonetheless, as expounded in the Word of God
is entirely incongruous with the Muslim belief. It is imperative,
however, to emphasize the biblical teaching in this connection.
It is inaccurate to say that conversion according to the
Gospel is a change of affiliation from one religion to another,
as many of our Muslim friends are led to believe. Conversion,
according the Word of God, is a profound and wonderful divine
intervention in the life of a sinful man, when God enables
him to turn away from wickedness and the dominion of Satan
to His marvelous light. Sin is the moral corruption that
entered the world as a result of the disobedience of our
representatives in the garden, namely Adam and Eve. Sin,
therefore, is not, as the Muslim assumes, a weakness or
lapse or mistake. It is the condition of alienation from
the holy God. The Bible speaks of sin as “lawlessness”
(1 John 3). Moreover, we need to differentiate between the
original sin, which Islam denies, and actual sin, which
we commit by virtue of being born in a state of falseness.
The Bible maintains that sin and guilt, seen in the light
of the fall, cannot be expunged by the performance of good
works or obedience to the law, or by believing in a creed
or dogma. There must also be an ultimate standard by which
we measure all ethical and moral behavior (Rom. 3:10-20;
Tit. 3:5-7; Heb. 9:9).
We cannot speak of conversion without speaking of salvation,
redemption and sanctification. The Bible says: “all
have sinned, whether Jew or gentile Muslim or Christian.
Therefore all need salvation from sin (Romans 1:18-3-18).
This salvation, nonetheless, comes only through the redemptive
work of the Lord Jesus Christ, and it is the end result
of what He has done. Whereas, we sin against the Holy God.
Two imperatives must take place, as far as the person is
concerned, prior to true conversion: faith and repentance.
Three elements of saving faith lead to true conversion.
First, the intellectual. The mind is open to the truth of
God’s word. Second, the emotional. The heart is gripped
through the truth by the working of God the Holy Spirit
. Third, trusting the Lord Jesus Christ in a steadfast obedience.
Likewise, there are three elements of true repentance, in
some way parallel to the elements of the saving faith. First,
the intellectual - when we acknowledge our state of sin.
Second, the emotional. It is the genuine sorrow for our
sin. Third, the inner motivation of the will to turn from
sin and ask for forgiveness through Jesus Christ.
Accordingly, any religious preoccupation with rituals will
never absolve a person’s sin. “Zeal without
knowledge” is nothing more than an attempt to suppress
the nagging guilt feelings by resorting to endless acts
of self-righteousness which, as we shall see later, “were
not able to clear the conscience of the worshiper”
(Heb.9:9), as the case is in Islam.
Who are the Sunni?
A Sunni is a member of the larger Muslim sect that encompasses
approximately ninety percent of the Middle Eastern Arab
Muslims. They claim that they represent the orthodox Islam.
The Arabic word Sunnah means “path,” “way,”
“custom” or “law.” The Sunni acknowledge
the first four Caliphs, the successors of Muhammad. While
Sunni do not believe that the caliphs acquired Muhammad’s
prophetic position, but they extended his political and
spiritual authority. The Sunni, however, are the majority
in Islam. Their Islamic beliefs and practices are based
on the Quran and the traditions rather than devotion to
the Imams, as is the case in Shiah Islam.
What is the Shariah?
The Shariah (path, track or passageway) is the Islamic law
derived from four sources: (1) the Quran, (2) the Sunnah,
(3) the Qiyas (analogy or measurements of past traditions
and their application for modern cases), and (4) the consensus
(the agreement of the prophets' companions on various points
not settled earlier, producing a consensus for the community).
It is described by the well-known Islamic scholar Schacht
as an “all-embracing body of religious duties, the
totality of Allah's commands that regulate the life of every
Muslim in all aspects; it comprises on an equal footing
ordinances regarding worship and ritual, as well as political
and legal rules” (1993,9). While the Shariah is practiced
only by some Islamic nations, the majority balance their
Islamic laws with secular codes. Such practice, however,
has energized a new movement of Islamic radical fundamentalism
calling for the return to “al-Usoliat” (fundamental-tenants
of Islam) as we shall discuss in more detail later. More
on this under the question: What is The Sacred Law?
Who are the Shiah?
The Shiah (sect of Islam) is also called the partisans of
Ali (son-in-law and cousin of the prophet Muhammad). The
Shiah recognizes Ali as the only leader of the Islamic community
and rejects the first three (Caliphs), giving the descendants
of Ali great reverence and authority and considering them
the only legitimate leaders in Islam. The majority of Shiah
live in Iran and Iraq. There are other pockets in Lebanon,
Syria and Turkey. In contrast to the Sunni, the Shiah sect
developed their own corpus of law and a system of theology.
The Shiah has split into different divisions. The Twelvers
are those who recognize twelve Imams while the Fivers recognize
only five Imams. The Ismailis is another division also called
the Seveners. They believe that a seventh Imam will emerge
some time in the future to establish a new order.
What is Hadith?
A Hadith is a tradition traced to the speeches and conversations
of the prophet of Islam, containing a variety of subjects
on most aspects of life.
Believing that Muhammad was incapable of doing wrong, his
followers scrupulously recorded his sayings and followed
them to the letter. During his lifetime, his sayings and
actions were considered a living example and normative standard
for all “al-Momonin” (believers). The Hadith,
however, was not written down until after Muhammad died.
It was not until the third century after Muhammad’s
death that an effort was made to write it down. Among the
traditionalists whose collections of the Sunnah have become
authoritative is al-Bukhari (A.D. 870). The Sunnah-as mentioned
above, is basically deduced from the Hadith or the sayings
of Muhammad and became second only to the Quran-the Muslims
holy book. Here we have to add two points. First, There
is no way of knowing which are the authentic hadiths. Muslims
developed a science of hadith criticism in orde to classify
the sound (Sahih) from the Weak (dhaif). This resulted in
the production of six major collections that were all later
accepted by Sunni Muslims. The most significant is of al-Bukhari
(d.870). Second, in addition to the six collections of hadith,
the Shiahs produced the saying of their imams (Muslim leaders
descendants of the fourth caliph Ali) and made them authoritative
collections normative for all aspects of life.
What is the influence of the Hadiths and tradition
upon the followers of Islam?
After the Quran, the Hadith became the most influential
factor in shaping the ethical, social, political, liturgical,
religious, and legal systems of Muslims, particularly the
Sunni sect. Our intention here is to avoid judging the motive
or the sincerity of this mode of such behavioral control,
for it is inevitable that in any educational process--secular
or religious--certain values and attitudes will be infused.
For this reason, however, education must be guided by the
right moral principles. Otherwise, any wrong mode of indoctrination
from the early stages of childhood has the potential for
forcing the mind to change its orientation and ultimately
captivating the conscience in a way that leaves little room
for correct belief or value.
Muhammad gave an absolute and concrete meaning to every
detail for the ritual of worship and religious practice.
The bulk of the followers’ personal and corporate
piety in their ritualistic acts of worship and daily life
were fashioned after his example. His customary ceremonies
continue to be observed by his followers without any modifications
or change. For example, his followers observe the ritual
of prayer in its content, time, and manner of performance
exactly as it was practiced and prescribed by the prophet.
The Quran reinforces the importance of this habitual practice
(2:110; 11:114; 17:78-79). Thus, both the symbols and the
contents become deeply embedded in the consciousness, and
therefore in the conscience, of every worshiper.
How does this contrast to the Gospel?
Islam is a religion, but a religion of law to its very core,
encompassing all facets of spiritual and temporal matters
of the “ummah” (community). Thus, the “iman”
(faith) of Islam is more than creeds and doctrine. For a
devout Muslim particularly of the Sunni sect, faith primarily
means the ordering of their lives according to a conscious
imitation of the actions of their Muslim prophet Muhammad.
Certainly, this strong law orientation makes Islam appealing
to the natural man, who thinks that he can gain worthiness
through self-effort and his own goodness. Pascal made a
keen observation in this connection, “Muhomet a pris
la voie de ressir humainement, Jesus Christ celle de perir
humainement” (Muhammad chose the way of human success,
Jesus Christ that of human defeat). Conformity and intense
bondage to the law as a means for salvation has left a deep
impression on the religious psyche of most Muslims, particularly
the Sunni. Moreover, this impression has been produced by
concrete acts of religious symbolisms that have colored
their religion and social ethics, as will be seen in the
following discussions. Jesus confronted the legalism of
the Judaizers and the Pharisees for missing the real intent
of the law by being enslaved to its letter. They were entangled
in the snare of works-righteousness, which becomes the foundation
of their faith. Such an orientation which fails to be motivated
by love and spurns the grace of God becomes a tragic religiosity
consumed by a destructive zeal which is not based on knowledge
(Galatians 1:13; Romans 10:1). Only grace, which is the
unique aspect of the Gospel, can fulfill the demands of
the law and emancipate the believer to live not according
to the flesh, but by the Spirit (cf. Romans 8:1-4).
Is the Allah of Islam the same as the God of the Bible?
From what has been said in the preceding discussion, it
is clear that Islam is indeed a modified mixture of Judaism
and Christianity. Moreover, in its main belief, Islam is
very much a "Theocentric"-more accuratly "Allahcentric"
religion. It is undeniable fact that Muslims are very much
sincere in worshiping one Allah with emphatic emphasis on
his oneness. However, their perception of the nature of
Allah is much different-and in my judgment far removed from
the Christian understanding as we shall see in the ensuing
The term ‘Allah’ referring to the God of the
Bible was popularized among Middle Eastern Christians via
the excellent ‘Van Dyck’ translation of the
Arabic Bible completed in 1864 by able Bible scholars and
experts in philology and linguistic sciences. The same term
is used also in the Quran. Nonetheless, both terms are loaded
with different theological meanings, as we shall see in
the ensuing discussion.
In the Arabic and Islamic usage, the term ‘Allah’
is a contraction of ‘al’ (the) and ‘ilah’(god),
which is a common term in pre-Islamic pagans’ Pantheon.
Muslim scholars today try to connect the term Allah with
the biblical name for God “Elohim,” while others
argue that the term is purely Arabic. In any case, Muhammad
undoubtedly was a revisionist who took the pre-Islamic name
Allah and loaded it with new meaning, borrowed from pre-Islamic
ideas, the Old and New Testaments, thus introducing Allah
as a “high god.” The testimony of the Quran
itself leaves no doubt that the worship of ‘al-ilah’
was an integral part of the worship system of pre-Islamic
Pantheon (Quran 29:65; 31:31; 26:61-63). The ninety-nine
traditional Islamic names for Allah are attributes of Allah,
most of which can be found in the Bible, except for a number
of crucial omissions and additions.
To what extent does Allah of Islam correspond to
the God of the Bible?
The ancient Arabian tribes were familiar with the concept
of “high god.” Muhammad, was a reformer who
took the same concept and loaded it with new meaning borrowed
from Pre-Islamic ideas, Old and New Testaments, and thus
introducing Allah as a “high god,” similar at
least in part to the God of the Jews and Christians. Perhaps
this was one of his strengths, being able to unite all the
tribes around the worship of the one god.
In order to deduce the Muslim concept of Allah in contrast
with the Bible, we need to look at their holy book. The
Quran introduces Allah in a number of ways contrary with
the biblical teaching; also raise questions about his nature
and moral character. The following are representative:
1) Allah is absolute unity and never triune. One finds
a number of references in the Quran such as: “Your
Allah is one Allah” (2:163). Islam is strictly and
radically a monotheistic religion. Muslim “Shehada”(witness),
known as the first pillar in Islamic creed, reads: “There
is no god but Allah and Muhammad is his apostle.”
The doctrine of “al-Tawhid” (the oneness) is
considered the core and kernel of Islamic theology and worldview
and the basis for morality. Muslims claim to be the only
true unitarians. This emphatic emphasis on the oneness of
Allah is embedded very deeply in the religion and the subconscious
of most Muslims, and often reflected in art, architecture,
and calligraphy. Furthermore, the Quran seems to deny the
Christian doctrine of the Trinity: “So believe in
Allah and his messenger, and say not Three.” (4:171).
Though a number of Christian apologists argue that Muhammad
was attacking the pagan polytheists of his day, nevertheless,
Muslims still deny the Christian doctrine of the Trinity.
2) Allah “the best of the ‘makereen’
(schemers). In Quran 3:54 we read: “And they (disbelievers)
schemed, and Allah schemed and Allah is the best of schemers.”
The Arabic scholarly al-Munjid dictionary correctly defines
the Arabic word ‘makereen’ as "deceivers."
Moreover, the Quran in 8:30, Allah is also called the best
deceiver, or cunning. In 4:90 Allah beguiles people; in
14:4 “Allah misleadeth whom he will and whom he will
he guideth.” I have not seen a cogent Muslim explanation
to these troubling pronouncements.
This leads us to another related theme connected with the
nature of Allah, namely predestination or fatalism. The
Bible speaks consistently of God’s sovereignty and
his plan of predestination, but never in fatalistic terms.
Most Christians assert the fact that the sovereignty of
God does not destroy the free will of man. For example,
the Larger Catechism states: “God from all eternity,
did by the most wise and holy counsel of His own will, freely,
and unchangeably ordain whatsoever comes to pass yet so,
as thereby neither is God the author of sin, nor is violence
offered to the will of the creatures... God hath endued
the will of man with natural liberty, that it is neither
forced, nor by any absolute necessity of nature, determined
to good or evil” (Eph. 1:11; Jam. 1:13; Acts 11:23;
Matth. 17: 12; Jam. 1:14; Duet. 30:19). Not so in Islam,
where we shall discover that all events and the will of
man are predetermined in such a way that all human efforts
are irrelevant. While an increasing number of Muslim scholars
today are attempting to show this doctrine in a better light,
nevertheless, they cannot escape the fact that conception
of fate (kada, kismet and qader) is embedded deep in the
Muslim theology, which finds its root in the absolute and
unconditional surrender to Allah’s decrees. A reading
of the Quran shows the following proclamations:
3) Everything determined by the Will of Allah: The Quran
declares, “Nor can a soul die except by God's leave,
the term being fixed as by writing” ( Quran 3.145).
“And with Him are the keys of the unseen treasures--none
knows them but He; and He knows what is in the land and
the sea, and there falls not a leaf but He knows it, nor
a grain in the darkness of the earth, nor anything green
nor dry but (it is all) in a clear book. (Quran 6:59). Say:
For myself I have no power to benefit, nor power to hurt,
save that which Allah willeth” (Quran 7:188); Say:
‘Nothing will happen to us except what Allah has decreed
for us...” (Quran 9:51).
4) Allah Predestines the Fate of Every Soul. We read: “The
guiding of them is not thy duty, but Allah guideth whom
He will” (Quran 2:272 ); “Whatever is in the
heavens and whatever is in the earth is Allah's; and whether
you manifest what is in your minds or hide it, Allah will
call you to account according to it; then He will forgive
whom He pleases and chastise whom He pleases, and Allah
has power over all things” (Quran 2:284) “Do
you not know that Allah-- His is the kingdom of the heavens
and the earth; He chastises whom He pleases; and forgives
whom He pleases and Allah has power over all things... (Quran
5) Allah causes people to err and some people are made
for hell. The following words of the Quran advance the notion
that Allah is the author of error: “Do you wish to
guide him whom Allah has caused to err? And whomsoever Allah
causes to err, you shall by no means find a way for him.”
(Quran 4:88); “Whomsoever Allah guides, he is the
one who follows the right way; and whomsoever He causes
to err, these are the losers. Many are the Jinns and men
we have made for Hell.” (Quran 7:178-179). ; My counsel
will not profit you if I were minded to advise you, if Allah’’s
will is to keep you astray...(Quran 11:34 );“And the
Word of thy Lord hath been fulfilled: Verily I shall fill
hell with the jinn and mankind together” (Quran 11:117-119
6) Allah leads people astray. The following Quranic pronouncements
shows the enigmatic character of Allah: “Allah leads
astray whomsoever He will and guides whomsoever he will”
(Quran 14:4); “... Such is Allah’s guidance,
wherewith He guideth whom He will. And him whom Allah sendeth
astray, for him there is no guide” (Quran 39:23);
“And whom Allah guides, there is none that can lead
him astray; is not Allah Mighty, the Lord of retribution?
... if Allah desire to afflict me with harm, be the removers
of His harm, or if Allah desire to show me mercy, be the
withholders of His mercy? (Quran 39:37-38); “He whom
Allah sendeth astray, for him there is no protecting friend
after Him. He whom Allah sendeth astray, for him there is
no road” (Quran 42:44, 46);
7) Allah Predetermines human Wills: When we read the following
verses in the context of the above characteristics of Allah,
we ascertain the fact that the human will is predetermined
and fixed by fate, leading to the resignation to one’s
future kismet with a sense of its unalterability: “Let
any who will, keep it in remembrance! But none will keep
it in remembrance except as Allah wills. He is the fount
of fear” (Quran 74:55-56). “This is an admonition:
Whosoever will, let him take a (straight) Path to his Lord.
But ye will not, except as Allah wills” (Quran 76:29-30);
“Unto whomsoever of you willeth to walk straight.
And ye will not, unless (it be) that Allah willeth, the
Lord of Creation” (Quran 81:28-29)
What does the Hadith (sayings of Muhammad) say about Predestination/fatalism?
Presuming that Muhammad is Allah’s consummate prophet,
his followers scrupulously recorded his sayings and followed
them to the letter. His sayings and actions were considered
a living Sunnah and normative standard for all believers-particularly
the Sunnite sect of Islam. The following are representative
from his sayings about human free will and predestination
quoted from the two collections of Muhammad sayings, recognized
by the majority of the Muslim world, namely Sahih Muslim
and Al-Bukhari: Vol. 8 No. 399 of Hadith we read the words
of Mohammad: "Adam and Moses argued with each other.
Moses said to Adam, 'O Adam! You are our father who disappointed
us and turned us out of Paradise.' Then Adam said to him
'Do you blame me for action which Allah had written in my
fate forty years before my creation…" Another
Hadith says: “Hudhaifa b. Usaid reported directly
from Allah's Messenger that lie said: When the drop of (semen)
remains in the womb for forty or fifty (days) or forty nights,
the angel comes and says: My Lord, will he be good or evil?
And both these things would be written. Then the angel says:
My Lord, would he be male or female? And both these things
are written. And his deeds and actions, his death, his livelihood;
these are also recorded. Then his document of destiny is
rolled and there is no, addition to and subtraction from
it” (Book 033, Number 6392).
“Ali reported that one day Allah's Messenger, was
sitting with a wood in his hand and he was scratching the
ground. He raised his head and said: There is not one amongst
you who has not been allotted his seat in Paradise or Hell.
They said: Allah's Messenger. then, why should we perform
good deeds, why not depend upon our destiny? Thereupon he
said. No, do perform good deeds, for everyone is facilitated
in that for which he has been created” (Book 033,
“Abu al-Aswad reported that 'Imran b Husain asked
him: What is your view, what the people do today in the
world, and strive for, is it something decreed for them
or preordained for them or will their fate in the Hereafter
be deterrained by the fact that their Prophets brought them
teaching which they did not act upon? I said: Of course,
it is something that is predetermined for them and preordained
for them. He (further) said: Then, would it not be an injustice
(to punish them)? I felt greatly disturbed because of that,
and said: Everything is created by Allah and lies in His
Power. He would not be questioned as to what He does, but
they would be questioned; thereupon he said to me: May Allah
have mercy upon you, I did not mean to ask you but for testing
your intelligence. Two men of the tribe of Muzaina came
to Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) and said: Allah's
Messenger, what is your opinion that the people do in the
world and strive for, is something decreed for them; something
preordained for them and will their fate in the Hereafter
be determined by the fact that their Prophets brought them
teachings which they did not act upon. And thus they became
deserving of punishment? Thereupon, he said: Of course,
it happens as it is decreed by Destiny and preordained for
them, (Book 033, Number 6406).
“I said, “O Allah's Apostle! Why should a doer
(people) try to do good deeds?”” The Prophet
said, “Everybody will find easy to do such deeds as
will lead him to his destined place for which he has been
created.” (Sahih Al-Bukhari, Volume 9, Book 93, Number
“Aisha, the mother of the believers, said that Allah’’s
Messenger (may peace be upon him) was called to lead the
funeral prayer of a child of the Ansar. I said: Allah's
Messenger, there is happiness for this child who is a bird
from the birds of Paradise for it committed no sin nor has
he reached the age when one can commit sin. He said: Aisha,
per adventure, it may be otherwise, because God created
for Paradise those who are fit for it while they were yet
in their father's loins and created for Hell those who are
to go to Hell. He created them for Hell while they were
yet in their father’’s loins (Sahih Muslim,
Book 033, Number 6436).
The famed Islamic theologian, al-Ghazali summarizes it
well: “No injustice can be conceived on the part of
Allah. It is in his power to pour down torrents upon mankind
and if he were to do it, his justice would not be arraigned.
There is nothing he can be tied to, to perform, nor can
any injustice be supposed of him, nor can he be under obligation
to any person whatever.”
What does the Biblical Revelation say about God?
Fairness calls for the acknowledgment that the majority
of Muslims have a high view of their absolute deity-Allah.
The term ‘Allahu Akbar’ or ‘al-takbir’
(Allah is most great), which is uttered frequently by Muslims
in the routine daily prayers and other occasions, coupled
with their recitation of some of the most excellent names
for Allah including his mercy and benevolence, is a reflection
of their devotion to him. The problem arrives when we come
to encounter Allah in different light as we have seen above
described in capricious terms. I will leave the answer to
Muslim scholars to reconcile the lack of harmony in these
conflicting accounts. In the mean time, let us gaze at the
God of the Bible as He has revealed Himself by tracing some
of His perfections throughout the Scripture, particularly
those that are relevant to our discussion in connection
with the Allah of Islam.
The God of the Bible is distinctive and great in at least
two ways: First, He is absolute and totally other than His
creation. Second, God is personal, imminent and approachable.
God is absolute and totally other than His creation. God
is totally other in a number of attributes, which according
to L. Berkhof are incommunicable (not shared by any human
being). These include the following: 1) “Self-existent.”
God is totally independent from any causation. 2) ”Unchanging.”
God’s perfection is unalterable; His perfection cannot
increase nor decrease, for He does not need any improvement
nor subject to any deterioration. He is infinitely unchangeable.
3)”Eternal and Infinite.” He exists from all
eternity; the first cause of every thing that exists; unlimited
by time and space. 4)”the Unity of God.” There
is only but one Divine God. He is not composed of different
parts or essences, but one in essence in His state of blessed
triunity. Other attributes setting Him apart from creation
include: 5)“Spirit and invisible.” God is not
composed of matter, and does not possess physical nature,
nor can He be confined by the span of time and matter. 6)“Creator.”
while distinct from all creation, He is the creator of everything
that exists. 7)“All-knowing.” The nature of
His knowledge is perfect; nothing in the past, the present
and the future escapes His perfect awareness. “All-powerful”
Yet, His power is conformed to His infinite goodness, never
employed capriciously. 7)“Sovereign.” There
is no limit to his absolute authority over the universe
and humanity. Nevertheless, His sovereignty is the ground
for the believer’s confidence, for His sovereignty
is an extension of all His perfections including His goodness
and righteousness. “Greatness” “For the
LORD your God is God of gods and Lord of lords, the great
God, mighty and awesome, who shows no partiality and accepts
no bribes.” (Deut. 10:17).
God is personal, imminent and approachable. He graciously
shared certain attributes with man in a limited measure.
To these God’s perfect moral attributes now we shall
turn, keeping in mind how they contrast to Allah as described
in specific passages in the Quran and Hadith as discussed
A) The God of the Bible is Holy. While the term “holy”
is mentioned only once in the Quran in connection with Allah,
the Bible, attributes holiness to God more than ninety two-times.
At the center of God’s perfections revealed in the
bible is His holiness. It is the essence of His moral character.
He is alone holy and all righteousness; morality finds its
origin in Him. God is always consistent with His moral purity.
“... His works are perfect,and all his ways are just.
A faithful God who does no wrong, upright and just is He”
(Deut. 32:4); “His way is perfect” (Ps. 18:30);
His “eyes are too pure to look on evil; cannot tolerate
wrong” (Hab. 1:13). Consequently, sin and iniquity
are foreign to Him and provoke His holy indignation.
B) The God of the Bible is trustworthy and faithful. He
never leads anyone astray nor entices any to do wrong: “The
Lord is abounding in love and faithfulness” (Exo.
34:6); “All the ways of the Lord are loving and faithful
for who keeps the demands of His covenant” (Ps. 25:10);
“God is faithful; He will not let you be tempted beyond
what you can bear” (1Cor. 10:13); “Those who
know your name will trust in you, for you, Lord, have never
forsaken those who seek you” (Ps. 9:10).
C) The God of the Bible is truthful. One of the disturbing
descriptions of Allah in the Quran-at least for me-was this
verse: “... and Allah schemed and Allah is the best
of schemers” (3:54). On the other hand, one of the
most encouraging attributes for God in the Bible in His
truthfulness. He can never be misleading, whimsical or arbitrary,
but is always consistent and faithful to all His promises.
"You know with all your heart and soul that not one
of all the good promises the LORD your God gave you has
failed. Every promise has been fulfilled; not one has failed."
(Josh 23:14); God, "... does not lie or change His
mind; for He is not a man, that He should change His mind"
(1 Sam. 15:29); "for the word of the Lord is right
and true; He is faithful in all He does" (Ps. 33:4);
"... God is truthful" (John 3:33).
D) The God of the Bible is loving and good. The distinct
biblical teaching on love finds its justification in the
character of God. While this emphasis is practically absent
in Islam, it is built intrinsically into the very nature
of the biblical God. The Bible says: "God is love"
(1 John 4:8). As far as I know, the Greek term “agape”
used in the Bible in connection with the unconditional love
of God is an exclusively Christian concept; it is not established
clearly in other religions, including Islam. Nothing in
us attracted God to love us. As fallen, sinful and rebellious
people nothing lovable and worthy is found in us. God's
supreme example of this kind of love was expressed on the
Cross, entirely by His grace.
God is good. The Word of God says: “O Lord...You
are good, and what you do is good, “How great is your
goodness, which you have stored up for those who fear you”
(Ps. 31:19;Ps. 119: 68). It is plain that God, unlike man,
He has goodness inherent in Himself, for He is eternally
good. Unlike other deities, the God of the Bible in never
vindictive and unpredictable, but always good and just.
His justice is consistent with His holiness, mercy, compassion,
graciousness, wisdom, longsuffering and patience.
Not so in Islam. Islam teaches that man is essentially
good. Such a high view of man’s goodness, based on
the denial of original sin, is also found in the early Christian
heresy of Pelagianism. Both Islam and Pelagius downplay
original sin, transmitted to all human beings as a result
of Adam’s fall. Thus man is capable of earning salvation
on his own by utilizing certain guidance from Allah and
observance of specific rules and rituals.
E) The God of the Bible is the God of grace. The basis
for God's Love is His nature and His grace manifested in
history in the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ.
The Bible says: "But God demonstrates his own love
for us in this: While we were sinners, Christ died for us"
(Rom 5:8). God's grace reverberates throughout the Bible.
In Exodus 34:6 we read: “The LORD, the compassionate
and gracious God, slow to anger, abounding in love and faithfulness,
maintaining love to thousands, and forgiving wickedness,
rebellion and sin.” The New Testament echoes the grace
of God in these words: “For it is by grace you have
been saved, through faith—and this not from yourselves,
it is the gift of God” (Eph. 2:8-9). Thus at the heart
of the Gospel is God’s redemptive grace. It is undeserved
grace: “All this is from God, who reconciled us to
himself through Christ and gave us the ministry of reconciliation”
(II Cor. 5:18).
In Islam, however, grace (‘Nemah’) is not understood
in a redemptive sense; rather, it is connected with common
grace, benefiting all mankind and connected with the idea
of bounty and material blessing and benevolence. It is true
that the idea of common grace is found in the Bible - God
cares, sustains his creation and restrains human society
from destroying itself by evil: “He causes his sun
to rise on the evil and the good, and sends rain on the
righteous and the unrighteous” (Matt. 5:45). Nonetheless,
this grace is not sufficient for salvation. It is God’s
special grace through His redemptive work in Christ by which
we are redeemed. God’s grace is always sufficient
and efficient; nothing can frustrate its purpose of saving
all those who embrace the savior.
F) The God of the Bible is knowable. Muslims do not hesitate
to assert that Allah is absolute incomprehensible unity,
which cannot be described by any human language, or by human
perception (Quran 42:11; 6:103). Furthermore, the multiple
names for Allah, according to Muslims, are not meant to
describe Allah’s essence, but to show that there is
no simplistic notion of Allah. All human languages, categories
and conventions cannot delineate his nature. The phrase
“Allah Akbar” (Allah is great), which summons
Muslims for prayer, is meant to remind the believers of
his absolute transcendency. Allah made his will known on
the pages of the Quran, and to a certain extent by the creation,
but he remains hidden, inaccessible in a personal way.
The Bible, however, describes God in a distinctive way.
We are told that God is a personal Being and has created
man in His own image; it seems most reasonable to believe
that He would have communion and fellowship with the beings
which He had created. This affirmation is echoed in numerous
passages in the Scripture:
1) God made himself known to us: “Then the man [Adam]
and his wife [Eve] heard the sound of the Lord God as He
was walking in the Garden.” (Gen 3:8); “The
Lord said to Abram . “Leave your country, your people
and your father’s household and go to the land I will
show you” (Gen. 12:1); “.. I know you by name”
(Exod. 33:17); “Before I formed you in the womb I
knew you, before you were born, I set you apart..”
(Jer. 1:5); “But now that you know God-or rather are
known by God-how is it that you are turning back to those
weak and miserable principles?” (Gal. 4:9).
2) God is known by His miraculous works: “Has any
god ever tried to take for himself one nation out of another
nation by testing, by testings, by miraculous signs and
wonders, by war, by a mighty hand and an outstretched arm,
or by great and awesome deeds,like all the things the LORD
your God did for you in Egypt before your very eyes?”
(Duet. 4:34); “Come and see the works of the LORD,...
Be still and know that I am God; I will be exalted in the
Earth” (Ps. 46:8;10); “Come and see what God
has done, how awesome His works on man’s behalf! He
turned the sea into dry land, they passed through the waters
on foot-come, let us rejoice in Him” (Ps. 66:5-6).
3) God is known by His creation: “O LORD, how majestic
is your name in all the earth!” (Ps. 8:1); “The
heavens declare the glory of God; the skies proclaim the
works of His hand. Day after day they pour forth speech;
night after night they display knowledge.” (Ps. 19:1-2);
“Since what may be known about God is plain to them,
because God has made it plain to them”; “For
although they knew God, they neither glorified him as God
nor gave thanks to him, but their thinking became futile
and their foolish hearts were darkened.” (Rom. 1:21).
4) God is knowable by His written Scripture: “all
Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking,
correcting and training in righteousness,” (2Tim.
3:16); “the Law of the Lord is perfect, reviving the
soul” (Ps. 19: 7); “And we have the word of
the prophets made more certain, and you will do well to
pay attention to it, as to a light shining in dark place,
until the day dawns and the morning star rises in your hearts.
Above all, you must understand that no prophecy of scripture
came about by the prophet’s own interpretation. For
prophecy never had its origin in the will of man, but men
spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.”
5) The God of the Bible is made known in Christ: Conceivably,
the heart of the Gospel is outlined in one verse: “The
Word became flesh and made his dwelling among us. We have
seen his glory, the glory of the One and Only, who came
from the Father, full of grace and truth” (John 1:14).
There are three main reasons why Christ came in the flesh:
a) He came to show us the Father: “Don’t you
know me, Philip, even after I have been among you such a
long time? Anyone who has seen me has seen the Father.”
(John 14:9); “No one knows the Son except the Father,
and no one knows the father except the Son and those to
whom the Son chooses to reveal Him” (Matt. 11:27);
“Jesus answered... “I and the Father are one”
(John 10:30). It is plain that Jesus claimed that in Him
alone God is perfectly revealed. The Shorter Catechism asks
the question: “What is God? Answer: “God is
a spirit, whose being, wisdom, power, holiness, justice,
goodness, and truth are infinite, eternal, and unchangeable.”
This definition is now personified in Jesus Christ. Such
a manifestation and full revelation of the Father in Jesus
Christ would at once set all abstract conceptions about
God at rest, making the Gospel the only viable and clear
disclosure of God to man.
b) To reconcile us to God: Reconciliation presupposes enmity.
Genesis 3 demonstrates the dawn of fear and guilt and alienation
from God because of man’s rebellion against the Holy
God. When Adam and Eve sinned, they realized their shame
and guilt and hid from God, experiencing objective guilt,
which can be removed only by God’s own initiative.
While the biblical account asserts that Adam's sin of disobedience
resulted in the total depravity of human nature and carried
with it far reaching consequences, it also provides the
remedy. The Gospel says of Christ: “He is the image
of the invisible God... and through Him to reconcile to
Himself all things whether things on earth or things in
heaven, by making peace through His blood, shed on the cross”
(Col. 1:15, 20). This change of attitude from hostility
to harmony is the central doctrine of redemptive history
where Christ took upon Himself the penalty which we deserve
in order to assuage the holy justice of God and restore
our broken relationship with Him. Hence, we are released
from a state of sin and fear to grace and freedom; for “...
God was reconciling the world to Himself in Christ, not
counting men’s sins against them” (2 Cor. 5:19).
As far as the Gospel is concerned, nothing in all religious
practices-no matter how intense, passionate and sincere
they are - can remove man’s guilt and bring him to
right relationship with his creator. Samuel Zwemer described
the Islamic religious practices as “barren formalism.”
The majority of Muslims see that their salvation rests upon
the total obedience to the sacred law and engagement in
meticulous performance of religious duties. Such conviction
results in definite inner crises which, according to Hebrews
9:9, will never clear the conscience. Legalism contradicts
the heart of the Christian message of reconciliation, which
can only come through faith in Jesus Christ.
An increasing number of adherents to Islam find themselves
troubled by tradition and are moving away from legalism
to a more mystical and personal way of worship. The Sufi
sect is very fascinating and worthy of much study. It evolved
to become a new “Tarikah” (way) within Islam
that moved away from blind obedience to tradition to a more
personal relationship with God by stressing certain themes.
Some of their major ideas overlap with some biblical and
Christian themes. Among these are the inward search for
God; the love of God; the immediacy of God (in contrast
with his absolute transcendence in traditional Islam); grace
(not necessarily the same Christian understanding of grace);
humility; love for one’s neighbor; personal communion
with God in the form of chanting, dancing, and repetition
of certain liturgical formulas.
c) He came to destroy the works of the Devil. The Word of
God clearly says: “Dear children, do not let anyone
lead you astray. He who does what is right is righteous,
just as He is righteous. He who does what is sinful is of
the devil, because the devil has been sinning from the beginning.
The reason the Son of God appeared was to destroy the devil’s
work” (1 John 3:7-8). Certainly, the devil has succeeded
in separating man from his fellowship with God in the garden
of Eden. However, as we have seen above, the reconciling
work of Christ has defeated the devil’s schemes and
work. Hope, forgiveness, cleansing from sin, fellowship
with God become possible in Christ. The promise of crushing
the devil’s head in Genesis 3:15 is now fulfilled
through Christ’s victory on the Cross of Calvary.
Jesus Christ now achieves what man’s religions were
unable to accomplish. “Therefore, there is no condemnation
for those who are in Christ Jesus, because through Christ
Jesus the law of the Spirit of life set me free from the
law of sin and death. For what the law was powerless to
do in that it was weakened by the sinful nature, God by
sending His own Son in the likeness of sinful man to be
a sin offering. And so He condemned sin is sinful man”
The Quran seems to describe Christ in divergent terms. Some,
however, substantiate the biblical narratives. For example,
the Quran refers to Christ as: The “Messiah”
(3:45); His virgin birth (3:47); Advocate to God (3; 45).
Another important designation of Jesus is “Word”
(cf. John 1:1). In Surah 3:45 translated literally it is,
“O Mary! God giveth thee glad tidings of a Word from
Him: his name will be Christ Jesus.” George Sale translates
this verse more literally from the original Arabic: “O
Mary! God sendeth thee good tidings, that thou shalt bear
the Word, proceeding from Himself; his name shall be Christ
Jesus” (Sale, George 1734). The “Word, proceeding
from Himself” seems to be correlative to John’s
affirmation of Christ’s eternality being incarnated
as Jesus the Messiah. Martin Luther says at this point:
“just as a man has a word in his heart, so also God
in His eternal majestic and Deity has a thought, a word
in his own heart, with himself. This word, which God the
Father has, is so entirely one with Him, so that there is
nothing in God which does not also belong to the Word, so
that when we see the Word we see God.” John illustrates
a great theological truth. Jesus belongs to a timeless eternity.
As Augustine says, ”He is in the beginning which has
6) The God of the Bible is approachable. In answering the
above stated question, Is God knowable in other religions?,
we concluded that the concept of god varies from one religion
to another. For some, the supreme deity remains hidden,
austere, inflexible and capricious; for others, he is an
abstract void that cannot be known, still for some he is
always silent, vague and impersonal.
In contrast, the Bible sketches for us a beautiful picture
of God being knowable and accessible in a personal manner.
Moses asks the rhetorical question: “What other nation
is so great as to have their gods near them the way the
LORD our God is near whenever we pray to Him?” (Duet.
4:7); “The Lord is near to all who call on Him, to
all who call on Him in truth. He fulfills the desires of
those who fear Him; He hears their cry and saves them.”
(Ps. 145:18); “Blessed are the pure in heart, for
they will see God” (Matt. 5:8); “But when you
pray, go to your room, close the door and pray to your father,
who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in
secret will reward you” (Matt. 6:6); “Therefore,
since we have been justified through faith, we have peace
with God through our Lord Jesus Christ, through whom we
have gained access by faith into this grace in which we
now stand. And we rejoice in the hope of the glory of God.”
(Rom. 5:1-2); “Come near to God and He will come near
to you” (Jam. 4:8).
7) God is known experientially by fellowship with Him through
Christ. “For the law was given through Moses; grace
and truth came through Jesus Christ. No one has ever seen
God, but God the One and Only, who is at the Father's side,
has made him known” (John 1:17-18); “We know
also that the Son of God has come and has given us understanding,
so that we may know him who is true. And we are in him who
is true--even in his Son Jesus Christ. He is the true God
and eternal life” (1 John 5:20).
What do the Quran and Hadith says about Woman’s
position in Islam?
The Bible describes man and women as equal in the eyes of
the Lord. The first chapter of the Bible declares both as
being created in the image of God. Jointly they were given
the mission of being fruitful and having dominion over the
earth (Gen. 1:27-28). In marriage both become one flesh,
an expression of union, fidelity and. (Gen. 2:23-24). The
Decalogue give honor to both father and mother (Exod. 20:12).
Contrary to the ethos of his day the Lord Jesus Christ,
gave women place of honor. The Scripture tells us that in
Christ there is no difference between male and female (Gal
3:28). While the role of spiritual leadership was given
to the husbands, but thy are commanded: “Husbands,
love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave
himself up for her” (Eph. 5:25). In contrast with
all other faiths past and present, there is no doubt that
the Bible portrays women as equal companion to man, though
have different role.
In contrast, the Oxford Encyclopedia of Modern Islamic World
argues that the position of women in early Islam was improved
in comparison with pre-Islamic period, nonetheless, it admits
that women are given less statues than men: “Quranic
verses do assign women’s testimony half the value
of men’s; permit men to unilaterally divorce their
wives; deny women custody rights over their children after
they reach a certain age; permit polygamy; and favor men
over women respecting inheritance.” (OEMIW, Vol. 4
It must be kept in mind that conflicts between traditional
and fundamentalist Muslims on one hand and reformists on
the other are continuing today. The traditional majority
is still hold on unyielding literal interpretation of the
teachings of the Quran and the Hadith concerning the position
and role of women, while the reformists are taking more
liberal definition. Below are representative teaching about
women in the Quran and the Hadith (Sayings of the prophet
Muhammad) taken from the Muhammad Pickthall’s translation:
- Concerning women’s rights the Quran says: "And
women shall have rights similar to the rights against them,
according to what is equitable; but men have a degree over
them..." (Surah 2:228); "To the male a portion
equal to that of two females..." (Quran Surah 4:11).
- The testimony of two women equals the witness of one man:
"And get two witnesses out of your own men, and if
there are not two men, then a man and two women such as
ye choose, for witness" (Quran 2:282).
- Husbands are permitted to scourge their wives: "Men
are in charge of women, because Allah hath made the one
of them to excel the other, as to those women on whose part
ye fear disloyalty and ill-conduct, Admonish them, refuse
to share their beds, scourge them..." (Quran 4:34)
- Polygamy is allowed in Islam: "...Marry of the women
who seem good to you, two, or three, or four; and if you
fear that ye cannot do justice (to so many) then one..."
(Quran 4:3). Muhammad was allowed to marry unlimited wives
according to the Quran 33:50).
- Women objects of pleasure? "Your women are a tilth
(a field to be ploughed) for you, so go to your tilth as
you will...” (Quran 2:223)
- A husband may divorce his wife for any reason he seems
fit, however, he must repeat verbally his intention to his
wife twice or three times for the divorce to be lawful (Quran
Very essential for Muslims understanding of the position
and role of women are the sayings of Muhammad. The following
maxims about women are narrated by Sahih Al-Bukhari. Al-Bukhari
(810-870AD) was the greatest traditionalist in Islam who
accumulated the Hadith of Muhammad which has been called
the most authoritative book after the Quran called Sahih
Al-Bukhari. He collected over 600,000 Hadith, but was reduced
to about 7,275. I shall not read into it, but certainly
these unusual teachings call for adequate explanation by
- Mohammed asked some women, "Isn't the witness of
a woman equal to half that of a man?" The women said,
"yes," he said, "This is because of the deficiency
of the woman's mind. " (Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 3:826)
- Mohammed said, "I was shown the Hell-fire and that
the majority of its dwellers are women. " Vol. 1:28,
301; Vol. 2:161; (Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 7:124).
- Mohammed said, " Bad omen is in the woman, the house
and the horse." (Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 7:30).
- "Narrated Aisha that the prophet married her when
she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when
she was nine years old" (Sahih Al-Bukhari Vol. 7:64).
What is the role of the Mosque in the Islamic Society?
The place and the role of the mosque also contribute to
the development and conditioning of the individuals in Muslim
society. We hinted earlier that the integration of worship
with social and political life was characteristic of the
early Islamic community. The first worship center in Islam
was the mosque of Muhammad at Medina. The important place
given to this sacred site is supplied by the Quran’s
commanding all Muslims to turn their eyes and hearts towards
it. “And from whatever place thou comest forth turn
thy face toward the sacred Mosque” (2:150). Moreover,
the third caliph, Uthman, said, “I heard the messenger
of Allah say: whoever builds a mosque desiring thereby Allah's
pleasure, Allah builds for him the like of it in paradise
(Ali 1977, 71).
In addition to its historical and important religious role,
the Islam has paid special care to the social and intellectual
significance of the mosque as a place from which the message
of Islam emerges. In a recent film by the Smithsonian World
titled Islam, the narrator made a perceptive remark in describing
the significance of the architecturally flat design of the
mosque in contrast to the towering church sanctuary. The
word “Mosque” means a place of prostration;
that is what Muslims do. They hug the earth--they are earthbound,
their concern is focused on the here and now. The horizontal
design of the mosque is indicative of this earthly concern.
This is a very different idea architecturally from the upward
reach of the cathedral. This is important to understand,
for Islam is a religion that seeks to establish its rule
here on earth rather than wait for the eschaton. The mosque
and the marketplace are always together.
Furthermore, from the beginning of Muhammad's mission he
used the mosque as a place for religious indoctrination.
His pedagogy was based on the absolute authority of the
Quran and the Tradition. Later generations followed Muhammad's
model by establishing the Sunni “Madrasah” (place
of teaching)-as we mentioned earlier, which is connected
closely with the mosque. Among these schools is the renowned
Al-Azhar in Egypt, which continues to be the voice of the
Muslim conscience and the seat of religious learning throughout
the Muslim world. Al-Azhar is considered the supreme theological
Islamic school. Its “ulama” (scholars) played
an important role in determining religious and ethical norms
for the Sunni community. The ulamas' “Fatwas”
(legal religious decrees) are often considered binding upon
the community. These decrees include matters such as drinking
of wine, usury, theft, adultery, apostasy, and women's right
How are Muslims instructed in the Mosque?
The Friday “khutbah” (sermon in the mosque)
delivered by the imam (leader) is usually crafted carefully
and charged with strong emotional appeal to Islamic principles.
The sermon, however, often addresses the current political
and social issues facing the Muslim community locally and
globally. Among the recurring themes in the Friday sermons
are the legacy of Muhammad, the supremacy of Islamic ethics
in comparison with those of the West, the national political
and Palestinian problems, appeals to the past glory of Islamic
civilization, and passionate calls for the rebuilding of
the Islamic empire.
Being aware of the power and authority that the mosque
exerts upon the masses, it is not unusual for the heads
of state in our day to try to win the approval of the imams.
Therefore, occasional appearances in mosques are customary
practice for the heads of states in the Middle East.
What is The (Shariah) Sacred Law?
Ellis Nelson, a noted writer and speaker on the issue of
conscience, describes Protestantism after its break with
the Roman Catholic church as a “religion of conscience.”
It turned the responsibility for the Christian life back
to the individual (Nelson 1978). By comparison, if Protestantism
is a religion of conscience, Islam can be called a religion
of law. As we observed earlier, Islam is both religion and
law, encompassing all facets of spiritual and temporal matters
of the “ummah” (community). From the early stages
of its development, two main sources of authorities were
adopted: the Quran and the Sunnah of the prophet who served
as God's spokesman, thereby performing the triple function
of administrator, judge, and executive.
As time progressed and Muslims found that the Quran and
the Sunnah were no longer sufficient to address all the
contemporary issues relating to the life of the community,
two more authorities were introduced. The first is “ijma”
(consensus). It is based on the collective opinions of the
“fuqaha” (jurists), and the “ulama”
(the learned). This branch was developed soon after the
death of Muhammad, and continues to be a guiding principle
for the application of the Shariah.
The second is “al-qiyas” (analogical reasoning
or deduction). These four sources (Quran, Sunnah, consensus,
analogical reasoning) became the canonical pillars on which
the sacred “Shariah law” stood.
How does the Arabic Language contribute to the
Most philologists agree that language constitutes a bond
and fosters a sense of affinity among people who speak the
same tongue. While this is true of the Arab Muslims, it
goes one step further. Stephen Neill rightly says that Arabic
is “one of the great bonds of unity in the Islamic
world” (1961, 45). Raphael Patai asserts that there
is a pervading consciousness of being one nation, irrespective
of the number of political units into which this one nation
is broken up. He attributes this consciousness to the Arabic
language. There can be no doubt that the Arabic language
is the most potent factor in both the creation and the maintenance
of the Arab nation, Arab unity, Arab brotherhood. In the
non-Arabic speaking world, as we have seen , there are several
groups of countries in which one and the same language is
spoken. However, only in the case of Arabic is the language
the factor that defines and determines membership in the
national aggregate. (Cf. 1983, 42,43)
This “membership in the national aggregate”
is determined basically, by the Islamic worldview and the
Arabic language. Islam and the Arabic language are the two
axioms that determine the concept of Ummah (nation) as advanced
by the Quran. These two axioms are considered by the majority
of Arab Muslims to be two inseparable aspects of one thing.
For instance, Arabs during the colonial period resisted
vehemently the attempts of the colonialists to replace Arabic--the
language of their holy book--with the English or French
language. Although the Arab World was divided into several
nations during the colonial period and still is the same
today, each however, has developed a national consciousness,
possesses a cultural cohesiveness expressed in a common
language. The famed Arab philologist Al-Tha'alibi (d. 1038)
Whoever loves the prophet loves the Arabs, and whoever loves
the Arabs loves the Arabic language in which the best of
books was revealed. Whomsoever God has guided to Islam .
. . believes that Muhammad is the best of prophets . . .
that the Arabs are the best of people... and that Arabic
is the best of languages. (Patai 1983,44)
Is it true that Muslims are more resistant to the Gospel
The Bible says that all people are born resisting the things
of God. We have seen earlier that the apostle Paul says
in Romans 1-2 that while God’s knowledge is clearly
seen in nature and in man’s conscience, man suppresses
this knowledge in unrighteousness. The point Paul makes
is that man’s dilemma results from his corrupted nature
and original sin in which he was born. This deviation from
truth is a result of deviation from true faith. However,
as we have discussed previously, certain cultural and religious
themes in the Islamic society makes the presentation of
the Gospel more challenging.